Woow. Intense man. That's was great. wellw ritten and riveting. My heart ahced for them.

Major angsty! Lots of fun though.

I have to tell you, you are an awesome, writer, I LOVE all your stories. I actually have read this beautiful one before, but failed to leave a review. Another absolutely beautifully done Puck and Rachel story. So angsty but so wonderful. Loved the endgame!

This was one of the first puckleberry fics I read so thank you for bringing me to this lovely fandom. This fic is fantastic. There is something so satisfying about a puckleberry endgame. I also like that you didn't villianize Puck's first wife. It was a nice touch to make it more real. Kudos to you!

Another epic puckleberry fic to satisfy the lack of puckleberry on Glee. Thank you! I always enjoy your stories.

That's the sound of my FEELS for all this delicious PANGST (puck angst) that you have woven so magically.

I cried. I legit CRIED. My heart broke for both him and Rachel, like, twenty times and then five extra times when I read the part about the miscarriage.

My favorite line ever? He laughs, though, as he walks down the street because if he's honest with himself, he carries her with him wherever he goes. That's headcanon. IT HAS TO BEEEEEEE.

amazing job. A freakin mazing.

Very good story, amazing writing! But heartbreaking, nonetheless. It was a bit (a lot!) depressing and yet I loved how the story was told though I hated how it made me feel (like crying, to be honest). Wonderful writing by an excellent author even if it messes with your breaking heart!

amazing! Love it!

Dear God... This made me CRY. Like... I felt Puck and Rachel's pain that it made me cry. And it's so much better because it had a happy ending. I LOVED this piece. It's seriously one of the best ones I've EVER read.

This story was so damn painful but really, really good. Too bad Rachel had to be clueless from the beginning. Puck's love for her was so deep and true, though. I'm glad they get to be together in the end.

oh, shit. Two seconds into this fic, and I know I'm gonna need my towel again. Damn.

Godamnit. Where is my Pirates of the Caribbean towel? I need to go sob into Will and Jack's faces.

"And she can't help that she doesn't return them that way."—WHAT THE FUCK? ARE YOU TRYING TO KILL ME HERE?

Okay wow that just about made me cry but it was so good and so well-written. Wonderful piece! :)

Good lord, woman, why would you keep rereading this one? It was depressing! Lol, I did like it, though, just made me sad :( As always, you did an amazing job!

thanks for the great read. X

This makes my heart ache:(((