Reviews for Minerva's Birthday Surprise |
---|
Missing Linka chapter 7 . 2/25/2008 THX That was really awesome ... In general, my mother doesn't like me talking about stories I've read, but she actually smiled and said that is sounded sweet when I told her about Minerva's present for Fawkes and the picture ... I also liked the Ro/Sev parts ... And the song was just so ... well, let's just say that I remembered a certain scene from a certain movie with the song ... *lmao* |
GryffinPhoenix3 chapter 7 . 5/13/2007 That was awesome! I loved it and thought that it was romantic! |
Geekerella chapter 7 . 9/25/2005 Brilliant. I love this story. Dumbldore/McGonagall just makes sense to me and I'm a total Snape/Hooch shipper so that just makes it perfect. My only slight criticism would be that you do need a beta to tighten up your spellings. |
Fin Ravel chapter 3 . 9/24/2005 Well well well, what have we here? A revision? It's good, especially the part when Rolanda catches Severus smiling, I especially like how you mentioned his secret crush and how it got started. Yeah, I'm a Sev/Ro junkie through and through. Chael |
Leta McGotor chapter 7 . 8/4/2005 I really love it. it was so funny but sad as well at some time. I liked the outcoming of the whole story. |
Litasha1987 chapter 7 . 4/26/2005 i love this story. *tear* Please but up another one soon I love your stories! Get craxking! LOL! Litasha |
Lasherblind chapter 6 . 3/25/2005 Hey, mistakes but still wicked,real cheerd me I cant isnt never is. |
Ice child chapter 2 . 3/25/2005 Really cool, story-loving the Harry/Ginny! sweet! Two thumbs up! And Olivia,if youre reading this,I'm sorry,but so should you be. :) |
Red Bess Rackham chapter 7 . 2/6/2005 Very cute. Good job. Now that you're done, maybe go back over it, using the Export/Backup thing, and fix some grammar and punctuation mistakes. They're not big tho, so its all good. :) |
Kayjaylc chapter 7 . 2/3/2005 Cute Story! I can totally see Albus make such an effort for his Tabby. :) Hugs, Kayjay |
ADandMMforever chapter 7 . 1/31/2005 Ok, #1; wonderful ending! *claps* #2; wait! It's ending? *sob* #3; I thought *I* was the typo queen! lol...I've changed my mind; you are the new typo queen... One example; "renew our vowels of love" don't you mean vows? and there are a ton more! and do you realized that 'I' when you are talking about yourself as in 'i wonder who could have put that mistletoe above us?', That I was supposed to be capitalized and there were a ton of those. It a bit hard to focus on the story when there are so many spelling and punctuation errors. #4; otherwise; I thought this was a wonderful story and I'm sad to see it end! #5; Post a new story! Post a new one now! All my love and waiting for more, ~Lily~ |
bigkihap chapter 7 . 1/31/2005 I really liked this story. I was feeling really moved until you started referring to the wedding vows as vowels... That kind of killed the mood for me. Oh well, all in all a great fic! -bigkihap. |
Quill of Minerva chapter 7 . 1/31/2005 aw glad minerva had a wonderful birthday |
Quill of Minerva chapter 6 . 1/31/2005 wonders what song Albus requested for them to play |
Red Bess Rackham chapter 5 . 1/29/2005 Not sure where you're going with this... but I'll stick with you. I noticed you had many sentences that didn't make a whole lot of sense. Maybe try getting a beta? Stick with this sroty, keep going, and good job. :) |