| Reviews for The Adventures of Kat and Sirrah in Middle Earth |
|---|
   Arrathir chapter 1 . 2/8/2006 You know, I'm not even going to comment on this. The typical "Mary Sue and her friend get zapped into Middle-Earth" plot is way overused and boring as Hell. |
| Sanjuno Shori Niko chapter 19 . 2/16/2004 Wotcher! Go get'em girls! Whe! I like this fic a lot! It's really funny, and very good! - Keep up the good work! - Mew! |
| elrohir lover chapter 19 . 2/2/2004 beter than the movie verse . |
| Lady Tamarisk chapter 19 . 12/18/2003 I think this is a really good story. In answer to your earlier question I think this may be technically a self-insert Mary Sue but I do not think that it matters. Keep writing. |
| The Authoress chapter 1 . 11/7/2003 Yeah, I know, its corrected in the final draft, but thats somewhere else. This has been done over about a year and a half so far, and towards the begining it kinda sucks. |
| pure evil chapter 5 . 11/7/2003 Boromir is the son of Denethor, not Theoden. Eomer is the nephew of Theoden and Theodred is Theoden's son. |
| KnowInsight chapter 19 . 11/6/2003 Great story. ) I hope to see more soon. Tenna' san' (Until than)... Am _ Now I'm gonna follow the girl's lead and get some sleep. D |
| KnowInsight chapter 16 . 11/5/2003 Okay, yes this is a Mary-Sueish in that it is self insertion and the girls have unsual powers, but it is not Mary-Sueish in that they are by no means perfect nor does a major character fall in love with them. So I'd call this a half-Mary Sue, kinda like a half-elf. D Perhaps you could summarize your story as a half-Mary Sue, that definately would be interesting. D Am _ |
| KnowInsight chapter 11 . 11/5/2003 D Am _ |
| KnowInsight chapter 8 . 11/4/2003 Well that's the most interesting way I'm seen Boromir saved. D I like it. Thanks for saving the big lug. ) Hopefully he'll learn a few things in that form. ) This is also the most interesting oddest insertion I've ever read. _ Go you. Hehe. Love their powers, they kick ass. Anyway off to read more. Tenna' ento lye omenta (Until next we meet)... Am _ |
| lizz chapter 18 . 10/11/2003 umm, kat there is no half on chap 19...maybe the comp ate it. |
| ember42 chapter 1 . 9/7/2003 cools storys |
| Grace chapter 18 . 9/5/2003 ::snfl:: ::pout:: ::bigger pout:: Where more story? Want more story. Please? -Grace |
| Grace chapter 18 . 7/12/2003 Wah! No new chapters in forever! ::snfl, snfl, pout:: ::fluttery lashes and hopeful look:: Pretty please? With the Fellowship member of your choice on top? ... Er, hold on, that's not how I meant it ... (Well, unless it gets us more chapters... ;)) Grace |
| Whispering Darkness chapter 18 . 6/8/2003 *bounces* YAH what a fun story! - Update soon, I wanna read more! - *bounces* |
