I like that you left it open-ended. I enjoyed it very much
-t

Altough i'm crying right now, i love the ending.. Of course i want to read a happily ever after ending but i don't know in some way this is a happy ending too.. İ'm sorry for my mistakes and if this is not make sense but i'm really still crying:)

was that the end? or is there more? I really like it

Many interesting things in this chapter. First, nice touch keeping the "egging" scene from the show, although this time Rachel is vegetarian instead of a vegan. It was a real surprise that here Tina is Matt's girlfriend instead of Mike, and what an irony that a man was singing "Sweet Caroline". Oooohhh, things are scalating between them. Let's keep reading to keep enjoying their evolving relationship and increasing hotness.

Haha, so far I love this AU. Is really interesting to see how the characters relate to each other here and, GASP! Artie can walk here! Good for him. Haha, the end of the chapter was awesome. Let's see what happens next.

Awesome story. I just love the pairing of Puck and Rach.

this story was amazing...I enjoyed it from word one...wow...great ending! bravo for a job well done!

This has got to be one of my favorite stories. Its short but you wrote it so damn well. Love puck and rachels relationship. And I totally love how you kept it casual it didn't need to be this epic love they somehow found in 3 months. But its obvious they like each other, you presented their feelings well without overstepping their characters. I also love santana in this she's so awesome. And I love how all of the other characters are involved. Its all so lovely.

Aww this is the cutest, most unique Puckleberry story I have ever read! I want them to get together so BADLY on glee! Write more puckleberry pleaseee!

Anime

hey there :9

I really loved this story! Its so beautifully written and the storyline is amazing :) I really came to understand rachel and puck and how they feel about the end of their summerfling and how they came to like each other so much..

I would really love to read a sequel maybe.. when they see each other again.. or whemn he visits her in New York or something like that!

HopesDieLast

This was brilliant! I liked seeing a wiser, more relaxed Rachel - it made the ending seem much more real. Thank you for writing this :).

Love this story! So cute! :)

This was done brilliantly! You're a very talented writer!

Being able to read this in its entirety was one of the great pleasures of returning home from vacation! The entire thing was terrific. I loved seeing how relaxed Rachel becomes and how seriously Puck takes it, even if they both refuse to put a label on things.

Finn threw me for a bit of a loop, but I thought Rachel falling into bed with him was realistic, if unfortunate. In a way it was nice for Rachel to finish things off with Finn on her own terms. I genuinely felt for Puck when Rachel told him (and of course she was going to tell him). Just because your feelings aren't entirely logical doesn't mean you don't have them.

Rachel singing for him (and Santana, and the rest of them) seemed very meaningful to me. I think she's been taking a break from RACHEL BERRY this summer, but that talent and ambition is always going to be a huge part of her, and I liked that she felt like she could share that with him. I also liked that it made him all kinds of hot for her!

And I have to say that I adored the ending. I love how much affection they obviously have for each other and yet they aren't making promises they can't keep, or compromising their futures for each other. And who knows? I mean, they're 18, practically babies and they've got an entire lifetime to find each other again, if the conditions are right.

Again, thank you so much for sharing this! I thoroughly enjoyed it! :)

So I was halfway through this story, and loving it by the way, when I realized who wrote it. I just said, "Oh, well, of course." I've read several of your stories, and I love them all. Great job!