Im cofused why did they call dawn a Winchester?

That was pretty cute:) and a great read. Thanks for sharing it

Holy crap, that was a million times more awesome than the previous story. Not to say that that one was bad! There really were times I wanted to reach over and smack the two of them in the head. Anyways, kudos!

Goddamn! You really messed up Riley! I never liked him, but it was more because he was so... plain. This actually makes him interesting ;)

I love this story! I so wish there would be a sequel;, even if it is a fluffy baby filled one. lol as always, amazing story. You have a true talent.

thank god "High School Sweethearts and Second Chances" had a sequel! this one was even more heart retching than the first one though. It made me cry so many times and broke my heart even more time! You are such a great writer! I actually could imagine Dean and Buffy doing all of the things that you wrote them doing. And now I'm crying because I have spent a week reading these stories and now they are finished and it is so sad that there is nothing more to read. But the ending, I wouldn't have wanted it any other way... thank you so much for these stories!

But will john make his deal in time? What lies in store for our heroes?

Oh, Nice twist there at the end. And something Buffy, with her savior complex, would totally do.

Cute

More! Want more! :) I just read both stories in one day. You are a great writer and got the people right. Thank you for a great read.

this is the best story i have read in a long time! WOW...I actually started crying multiple times :)

I loved this story! You are so talented at weaving together their universes and making them work! I'm so glad Sam and Dawnie got together :) About time don't you think? Anyway, wonderful story and I hope you write more soon! :)

Best story ever.

One of my favorite stories ever! It was so cute and it had me on the edge of my seat the whole time.

Sooo I've finally managed to catch up with this story. I've been mad swamped and also isn't sending me my email alerts (grumble grumble). Anyway, I LOVED this story - such a great sequel to one of the best Buffy/Dean fics out there.

I really liked how you balanced out all the present day angst with the sweet snippets of their past - it was great to see what happened to them after the end of High School Sweethearts.

And also the Dawn/Sam relationship was very cute - and I don't usually like that pairing.

Brilliant, brilliant ending!