That was certainly something

This deserves a continuation. :o I luved it soooo much!

Read this a couple times, I always love it.

XD the end paragraph wraps everything up nicely and I like the rest of the story as well

(Since im new to SPN-fics) this is the first fic with Dean being bottom but I like the fic, very nice

i'd kinda like to see more of these two...

Lolz I don't see how watching glee got you here but I liked it :)

I love this!

brill totally brill :) love it

Like the premise. Wish I could say I found the porn hot, but no prep and especially no lube ESPECIALLY in a virgin hole ripping, blood and immense pain. Not pleasure. Hard to get past, sorry.

holy...wow. This was...um, yeah. Really good. I liked it. wow, that didn't sound lame at all

love glee & supernatural! this was excellent! haha. any chance for more?

Ok, the ending is awesome but PLEASE tell me there'll be more of this. I liked that Cas tries to be strong but in the end believes he's the guy everyone says he is. And I loved how Dean was conflicted but tempted and he can *see* who Cas is and wants to know more.

Long time stalker, first time reviewing. So, I kind of love everything you write. This, however, made me make a noise as I was reading it on the mobile site on public transit that made the attractive man seated across from me raise an eyebrow.I think you broke my lady parts with hotness. In public. Keep them coming, please!

There are not words to explain how offended I am that this story only has eleven reviews.

Because it was cute and weird, and maybe a little rough around the edges (more than just a LITTLE rough if you're Dean), but come on. Dean playing catcher is my favorite. FAVORITE. And the mental image of Cas dressed as a cheerleader was just kind of hilarious.

But like hilarious in that way where you're trying to be sympathetic and not laugh, but you have to hold a hand up to your mouth because you just keep smiling, and you can't talk because it comes out shaky and high-pitched. Because ooohhhhh the indignity. OHHHHH the indignity.

So I really liked the part where Cas yanked the condom off. Not because it was sexy or raw sex is super hot, but because that is SO what teenagers do. Jesus God almighty, it's sort of a miracle so many of us escape high school without incurable STDs.

And yes. The way you wrote them here they could completely fit in with the cast at Mckinley High. Not too much Santana, not too much Kurt (because I see him there), not too much Karofsky, and not too much Finn (yup, he's there too).

But most importantly of all, I was watching the latest episode of Glee and for some reason, when I was not snickering at the way Lea Michele's mouth looks when it's open and sad (sort of like Kermit's) and trying not to apply my own personal sadness to the funeral, I kept meandering back to this story and thinking, "This show would be way better with the cast of Supernatural."

It might have had a lot to do with Lea's unattractive gaping hole of a mouth. IT'S HUGE. She can probably fit her whole fist plus a hamster in there.

Hmm that last sentence didn't come out like I thought it would. Note to self: do not talk about fists and small rodents in conjunction with smutty stories.