Reviews for No More |
---|
AndurilofTolkien chapter 1 . 4/19/2017 like |
AlickyNicholas chapter 1 . 10/19/2012 Sigh. Beautiful. I like the idea that he eventually chose to sail rather than linger, and I can see it happening exactly this way. Reading this piece was like watching it on film. :) |
Darkover chapter 1 . 7/9/2011 In this story, you did a good job of portraying the world-weariness that produces "sea-longing" in Elves. Thranduil may be a king, but he misses his loved ones, and even an Elven-king can become weary of the world with the passage of time. The dialogue was as good as the characterization. Well done. Sincerely, Darkover |
ziggy3 chapter 1 . 5/12/2011 The real end to LOTR - Thranduil leaving these shores and this is so well done of course. I can visualise this absoultely cleary and identify more than I thought possilbe with his exhaustion in leading and constantly being the figurehead, never letting up and needing Galion to comfort him with assurances of friendship. Love your Galion. |
Nieriel Raina chapter 1 . 5/10/2011 Lovely! I love the way you depict the relationship between Galion and Thranduil in this piece. :) BTW, your formatting is in a fuddle. It's all in italics. Thought you'd want to know, meldis. :) |
Mirwalker chapter 1 . 5/9/2011 Huzzah for a piece that looks beyond the charaters at stage front, and swiftly gives us insight through those less in Tolkien's focus. You've well-balanced both the intimacy and the positional difference between the two, suggesting Sam and Frodo weren't the only brothers across class lines... Thanks for sharing! |
GreenGreatDragon chapter 1 . 5/7/2011 wonderful! i love galion stories; he certainly doesn't get all the attention he deserves. i like how you built such a relationship in such a short time, too. and thranduil was very relate-able. very well done! |
Song in the woods chapter 1 . 5/7/2011 And thank the powers that be for Galion. He lasted a long time, and thankfully he has his friend to help him make it "home". |