OMG thanks for this! It's so well-written and reads like an actual episode! I laughed a lot! KUDOS!

This is the most in character fix I've ever read! I feel like I've just watched an episode! Especially the end part with Abed and Troy.

Okay, that was just so Community!

This is great so far. You've got their personalities and failed attempts to imitate one another's personalities down really well.

A really fantastic read, if only because it apes the show's writing style so well. And since Community is such a well-written show, I'm really impressed with how well you did with the characters! I'm always intimidated writing fanfiction for things that are already exceptionally well written - not to mention witty and genre savvy (Ahem, Community), because how can you hope to live up? All in all, you did a great job, and the text wasn't bogged down by superfluous details or descriptions. The pacing was as brisk as an episode of the show, and you kept things interesting and funny throughout! Great job!

This is so well-written. I really enjoyed the mannerisms of the characters, as well as the characters playing each other. Jeff’s sarcastic quips, Shirley’s religious talk, and Pierce… just being Pierce were all stand-outs to me. They way that you wrote all the members of the study group felt less like a piece of Fanfiction, and much more like an episode of the show, just in written form. Very well done.

And when they swap personalities, to show that there’s more to them than what each other thinks and how they believe they’re perceived by the rest of the study group, the way that you went about that was very Community-esk and I loved the message there. Going through it with Pierce, Britta and Abed on one end, and Annie and Jeff on the other was a really nice moment. The reference to one of the ‘90-second study break’ episodes was also a really nice touch and one that I wasn't expecting.

The one thing I don’t understand is why you weren't contacted to help out with Season 4. “Freaky Thursday” is streets ahead of what Season 4 was, and I'm positive that you could've made Season 4 turn out a lot better than it did if you had have written for it.

u have a true talent! 'i can crack walnuts with my ass' LMAO!

AMAZING

LOVE

Really good, and kind of ambitious. Must have been a nightmare to keep track of "who plays who" while writing. I'm impressed as hell, the charcters are really good and Pierce as Troy is fantastic.

This was fantastic! You did several things amazingly well.

First of all, characterization; I don't think I've ever read such a good Pierce before.

Secondly, characterization within characterization; Somehow, I believe that this is exactly how the gang would act if they were pretending to be each other. Abed would be the best impersonator and Britta the worst. Shirley would be really excited when she nailed a Britta line, and Annie would use her Winger-dom as an excuse to show Jeff what an ass he can be.

And, thirdly, the UST. I loved the Jeff/Annie moments. Not over the top and very in character. Well done!

This was so fun I loved it :)

Great fic! As your many other comments have said, you were spot on for characterizations. Happy this was a recommended fic that I followed from TV Tropes

Really really impressively in-character. You not only managed to write all seven personalities, you managed to write them pretending to be each other. That's an incredible writing feat that you ought to be very proud of. Kudos.

OH MY GOD. I love this to pieces! When I first read the summary, I thought it was a perfect scenario the show has yet to do, and when I started reading it became SO much more than I expected. Everyone was so perfectly in character (and the dialogue killed me), and the entire fic was not only funny but also very true to the spirit of the show. You had everyone's voices down, it was astounding. This totally could've been an episode.

Also: the end tag with Troy and Abed impersonating Jeff and Annie? PERFECT.