Hello, 10 years later here but idc. I LOVE CARLISLE SO MUCH I CANT this fic is soooooooo good

how could u kill Carlisle why not Edward or bella or renesmea?:'(

Cool story!

Ridiculously sad and nicely written. You made me cry. I think, mostly because, of what happened during the movie...

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!

OMG I almost freaking cried in the movie when Carlisle died but was so happy when he was back he was and still is my favorite I love it and this but both almost made me cry luv ya

AJ

THis is seriously well written. Can I just ask , why does aro owe carlisle?

I know this is an old story, but it was very good, albeit sad. So sad. If a sacrifice had been the deal Aro was forcing, Carlisle definitely would have made the decision that it be him; so as much as I wanted more action in the book, I'm glad none of the Cullens were lost...

Good one-shot.

This is so sad... but what I would imagine how something so tragic would happen. Nicely written.

The story was good, but you shouldn't have made it that Carlisle dies, because none of the cullens would never let that happen and I am a big fan of Carlisle.

Thats sad D: It was a good story but i love Carlisle

it was really good and i think u shud rite a sequel

but...but...but but but but but...but...-cries histerically-

YOU CAN'T KILL CARLISLE! BRING HIM BACK BRING HIM BACK! MAKE THEM LIKE FAKE THAT HE WAS DEAD AND MAKE HIM COME BACK! .

great story. still crying... next chapter?

Ahh! Sob! No no no Not Carlisle! Aww Cute story I loved it, but it made me cry! :) Good job though