This is the first icarly fanfic I have ever read, ive hardly even watched the show ... But this is truly amazing and well written! I love it!

One of the best stories I've seen on this site. I especially liked the ending to this chapter Sam is beginning to change, for the better I think.

This story has talent. You killed off Carly but at the same time managed to keep her character in the story. I always wondered how Sam and Freddie would react in regards to her death, and I think you played it out very well. I even enjoy the pairing of Melissa and Spencer to an extent. They seem to be the perfect couple in this story.

My only concern in this story is that Melanie and Freddie will get together, you seem like a Seddie supporter. And the story claims to be a Sam/Freddie romance but it seems as though you are setting them up to be the perfect couple. This frightens me, it does. That would be horrible.

Anyway, I really want to push you to continue writing. You have a talent much like this story and I am enjoying it. Thank you so much for the oppurtunity to read one of your works. The story is realistic and on-character. :)

-Ellen Marie

Update!

When will the Seddie action happen?

I started reading after the prologue, and I almost burst into tears! This is sad, but I love it! This story is a real tear jerker. Good job.

Awwww, I was close to tears at the end of that. New chapter soon pwease! :)

Wonderful!

great chapter!

Awwww I loved Sam's prayer :')

Poor Sam, nice view on her dad.

i looove this story! so much drama haha

Great chap

I still can't get over how awesome it was that Freddie punched his dad like that. xD New chapter soon please!

I almost feel sorry for Jake.

Wonderful!