You did a heartwarming job of showing the comfort and power that comes from the unspoken words between friends

Thoughtfully written and warmly. The song really set the tone, which I think you retained consistently throughout. The song I'm not certain fit perfectly, but then a 'modern' anything tends to jar somewhat against JRR Tolkien's world.

Insightful with some of Frodos thoughts, and then a little awkard perhaps in transitioning between his inner world and what was going on without (dialogue, character interaction), but all in all it came out well and consistently. _

(You can do better! No, I'm kidding - I just couldn't quite help echoing what you wrote in a review to me.)

And as an afterthought, I'd like to hear your thoughts on my LOTR piece, if possible. You wouldn't mind, would you? Well keep writing.

Toodles - IMP

Aw, that's sweet. Poor hobbits had to go through a lot and this just has them perfectly. Very good!

Oh my Eru! That is so adorable... and so sad! *begins to sob in the corner*

(Eyebrows shoot up and eyes get a bit misty.) Aww..! Dangit, that's sweet. You had me a bit nervous though when Sam rolled into/onto Frodo... O_O Funny you mentioned food when you described Sam's eyes... O_O (finally laughs, despite herself) Good thing you made that note about no slash. Anywho, the rest was really cute. When Sam was telling Frodo he would never break his promises, I got a vivid mental image of Sam tweaking Frodo's nose. o_O Don't ask me why... Probably 'cause I read Orangeblossom Brambleburr's "Shire Tales in Rivendell" story yesterday (it's good, by the way). Okay, I'm getting distracted.. Good job! (Good choice on a song too. The next to the last verse sounded like it would come straight out of Frodo's mouth.) Woohooo!

That is so sweet I started crying. It was very well written. Please write more sing fics!

well its strange certainly but well written, i like the way u can incoropate a song into a story, definatelly unusual, but theres definatelly a talent in you for this sort of thing. However, having read the book and seeing the friendship between frodo and sam, you do make them seem just a little bit more than friends in this. For example "They fell asleep like that, entwined in each other's arms."

But anyway, I enjoyed readin it natz, well written.

Like I did not start histaricley crting in the movie during the Sam Frodo sean(the best part) I seem to spend more money on tisuse then any thing else. How wonderfull you diserve an award. I want more!

**squeak!** THAT IS SO SWEET!

This is so wounderful! I had to put it under favoriets .Thank you for sharing it with us .(-:

Awwwwwwww *sniffle* I absolutely loooooovee Frodo and Sam fics. They are the best, especially the ones that show what true friends they really become during their trip through Mordor. THANK YOU for writing this.

'Cause God forbid anyone thinks they're gay.

Awwwww...! That was beautiful. Though I do think Frodo and Sam love each other a bit deeper than friends. Which is my opinion. But who knows? Mr. Tolkien is dead, so no one knows for sure, eh? But it was beautiful, even if you didn't write it with a romance implied. Bravo. _

*sniff sniff* That... was so beautiful! I am really fond of the hobbits and their friendship. And I, personally, thought that it was so beautiful in the end, when Sam was drowning and Frodo saved him! OMG! I felt like crying! Bravo! Keep up the good work!

Very sweet and written very well. Very nice communication between Sam and Frodo :-) And I like the way you can keep it 'friendly', without turning the fic into a *LOL* .. romance.