This is amazing! I'm astounded by how few reviews you have for this story.
Chapter 1 was quick and and gave an overview of the situation without diving into unnecessary topics. Definitely one of the best first chapters I've ever read. As for the read of the story, great progression while everyone stay so in character. Unusually I'm not a fan of stpry that have creddie in it, but I actually didn't mind this at all.
Wonderful job,
~Uni

This is the only Seddie fic I've read that doesn't have an OOC Sam in it. Great job :)

Awww I luv it! 3

The Fray is blasting from my computers speakers and I read this whilst that went on and bravo. I need tissues my allergies are a killer tonight.

I loved this story especially when sam was looking at the shays christmas decoration and freddie not having a present for her. It broke my heart and brought tears to my eyes!xx

Awe that was so cute! I think that was the first time in a long time that I have read a story and didn't have any complaints about it. You wrote all of the characters as they were supposed to be, and I don't remember finding to many grammatical errors either. I love how even after they're together Sam still acts the same.I always hate how after Sam and Freddie get together she seems to loser her Sam-ness. She gets all soft and girly. Changing a little is fine because her being mean to him because she's scared of showing her true emotions is a common known theory. But, I don't think if that is the case even after they were together she would drop the act and go into full on girl mode. Anywho, I appear to be getting long winded... boy I've gotta stop review at 3 am. I really did love the story though. Good job!

~Saxie

I thoroughly enjoyed reading this! Definitely a favorite of mine.

I am In LOVE with this story! Thank you so much for writing it! I hope you write more like this. Love how you write the characters so well :)

really great story, and you did a great job of showing the love triangle and friendship as mature and in-character. I loved how you showed Sam, trying to deal with being in love with Freddie while he's with Carly, and then Freddie who couldn't really deny their chemistry, and seeing Carly trying to ignore what was really going on, and then how everything blew up, but was able to be fixed in the end. Great epilogue- it was so refreshing after the drama, and not sappy. thanks for writing.

Love it! Absolutely, positively LOVE IT! I think it's the perfect mix of angst and like in real life. ;)

great story

That was so perfect! It was so real, I can't believe it! It was amazing and showed it all so perfectly. It was the most amazing and rockin thing ever. I swear to the gods, no lie. You have an amazing voice and had me rooting for Sam the entire time.

aW! I love it(:

Hey,

I absolutely loved this story. A lot of writers don't know how to portray the characters as they really are, but you did a perfect job of it. Well done.

"You know, I'm open to any suggestions," Sam offered, "Would you like me to make whale noises when we next make-out?"

"You already do."

-

LOL!

I really loved this story. Really funny and sweet all at the same time. I'll definatly be reading some of your future works. Keep up the good work!