I sure wish this is how it had happened on the show! Very good!

So beautifully written and emotionally compelling.

This is SO DARN GOOD

Much angst, but I like, oh I i/like/i/ the way you write. Thank you!

Poor Sammy! Yay Dean! Good story!

Right, this is the third story of yours I've read, and I've come to the conclusion that you are a genius. Plain and simple. Great job :)

Nope. I didn't feel a thing. Didn't shed a single tear. Nada. Zilch.

*internally dies*

This story-where and how do I even begin?! It was beautiful work for one, and definitely a tissue grabber! Denial and weak sarcasm aside, you had me full out sobbing and using my blanket as my snot-rag (I couldn't bring myself to leave my room and face my family, looking like an utter train wreck). The way you've written Sam and Dean are believable-time and time again, we've seen Sam so willing to die canonically for the greater good and for redemption its scary, so his attempts at suicide here are believable (and horrifically terrifying). His emotional state-oh my Chuck, I want to hate you for putting Sam through so much pain, but you've done it so beautifully, I just can't.

As for Dean-his love for his brother-his dedication-and his stupid self-blame (I just want to shake him sometimes and scream out the fact that not everything is his fault!), I just wanna wrap my arms around him-I want to wrap my arms around them both and hiss at anyone who wants to hurt them.

I just can't right now...So I think I'll just bury under all my blankets now and cry like there's no tomorrow. Thanks for carving my heart out and stepping all over it.

This made me smile and tear up T-T

Kicked me right in the feels and I loved it. OMG! xo

Whoa. Awesome take on how this could have played out. Very in character and horribly believable. Oh this was so horrible for both Sam and Dean. So well written. I was on the edge of my seat the entire time.

My poor Sammy! Thank goodness for Dean and that tree! Such amazing work! Nicely written!

Amazing fic, just wow :)

Almost as awesome as the show. You rock!

I've read this multiple times now and it is SO AMAZING oh god I love both the angst and how Dean so perfectly makes it better. Fantastic one-shot :)

Oh god, that was horrible and fantastic at the same time!