Love it! Evil penny. Nice. Great concept.

Love it!

Oh, woah, this is incredible! The last one is just chilling. :)

I love how each possibility gets darker and darker. Very lovely, all around

Reading this was painful in a good way.

(btw, I really liked how you separated each segment with 'She falls for him in pieces')

Wow. Dark, but good! I like it alot.

And a teensy part of me (which is being rebuked by the rest) really wishes this had happened in the original.

Woah. That's really nifty. I'm impressed by this idea.

I... really want more of that last universe right there. So bad.

This was really beautiful. I also loved the second one, where she KNOWS.

But yes. More of the last one, please.

The possibilities are positively tantalizing. kudos.

A very interesting idea of what can happen in alternate universes...I wish so badly that it happened in the original.

Nicely written. I like the little twists on the original story, and the repeating line, "She falls for him in pieces." Please, continue with Dr. Horrible stories!

I loved the style of this. Its well written. I also like the idea of Penny being evil. Not hurting anyone, but evil. Nice.

Really wonderful, and definitely the way things should have been. :) Well done.

Wow...incredible.

This is just really together, really touching and really well done.

I'm so glad you wrote this.

This is really sweet. Love to see Penny stand up for herself.