Reviews for Redemption (It's My Fault...)
bhunjimko chapter 22 . 7/16/2011
Dear Author,

I know I'm many years late in saying this and you are probably no longer around, but I was unfortunately rather late in reading it. I read the books throughout my childhood and just watched the final Harry Potter movie after which I was dismayed that it had to come to an end.

However, your story has rebirthed my love in new and unexpected ways, even so far as to make me cry again. It made me realize, no series ever has to come to and end. With fiction like yours, new material is possible and although fan-made, just as fruitful and exciting.

Because of this fic, I'm going to start all over again. I'm going to read the books to my kid-brother and during the next two weeks concerning the first book, I will think of your fic dearly every time I read p-p-poor st-stuttering P-P-Professer Q-Quirrell.

A thousand thanks,

bhunjimko
Rhi chapter 22 . 5/17/2002
You are a very good writer. I may not have agreed with everything you did with ghosts

or everything you said, but that was the best part. I could move past the things I didn't

agree with and just enjoy the story. I like authors who can make me believe things I

normally wouldn't.

I would have liked to have seen you, maybe, do some research on what historic ghosts

could and could not do. You said many times that you didn't know what ghosts were like

and I think a little reading could have solved that. There were some inconsistencies, but

the story worked in spite of them, almost around them. That takes skill.

You have a wonderful grasp on character development, descriptive detail, and plot. I am

very much looking forward to reading your other pieces.

And if I can ever get my idea to fly I would very much like to borrow your description of

the Ravenclaw common room. It just seemed to fit so well, and was one of my favorite

parts of the story.

You have talent. Nothing funny. I just like talent. *Grin* Keep up the good work.
Rhi chapter 15 . 5/9/2002
That's right, Rhi, as in the one from PHF. I was going to wait until I'd finished the whole thing before reviewing, but this chapter just blew me away. I laughed once, when I realised that this was indeed the Sev I knew. But by the time I got to the end I was blinking back tears. You are truly a great author, even if you do stray from the canon at certain points. I'm going to greatly enjoy reading all of your other works this summer.
Bridget Jones Wanton Sex Goddess chapter 22 . 4/3/2002
Oh, brilliant, just brilliant. Excellent, excellent, excellent story you've got here!
Bridget Jones Wanton Sex Goddess chapter 15 . 4/3/2002
Oh, I like this story very much indeed.
Bridget Jones Wanton Sex Goddess chapter 9 . 4/3/2002
Generally I find that first person can be rather limiting (or *unreliable* as the case may be) to the action of the story but I think you're handling it quite well! Just had to make a quick comment on that and now I'm off to read the rest.
Bridget Jones Wanton Sex Goddess chapter 8 . 4/3/2002
Bloody good chapter!
Tarash chapter 13 . 3/9/2002
*Two thumbs up* Lovely story, read it all. Very nice portrayel of Q and his background.

BTW, I'm interested in those pictures you mentioned. Any chance of sending to the above mentioned email? Thanks in advance!
Moony Girl chapter 22 . 2/1/2002
Alright, I'm back for one more review...go to the URL to see it:

moony_girl13/congrats.x

I'm sorry it's so badly drawn...I have no drawing skills whatsoever and I was drawing without references, so I probably got some things wrong _
Lady Snape chapter 11 . 1/26/2002
Totally awesome! This is one of those fics that I print and read over and over again! Darn good stuff!
Sevvie the loveliest Slytherin babe chapter 22 . 1/25/2002
OKay, last review from me for this pic. :(

Sappiness! all the sappiness! Do I want a sequel? I think you know the answer to that.
ThreeOranges chapter 22 . 1/25/2002
Sweet epilogue! And yes, a sequel would certainly be interesting, but if Celly and the twins should appear in "Credo" I will consider that a sequel of sorts.

I hate to say goodbye to this fic! But at least the promise of more writing from you is some consolation. Now go console me! NOW! :-)
Draco the Lizard chapter 21 . 1/25/2002
Aww, such a cute li'l chappie! Very good way of redeeming our beloved Quirrell.

And what's with the Monty Python lines from Severa?
Iphigenia1 chapter 21 . 1/25/2002
Oh yes! I sang "The Echo" for All State Choir one year. The arrangement of it that we did is so beautiful, and it is such a perfect poem for Celly and Will. *wipes tear away* What a sad ending (except of course for me getting together with Lee Jordan), but it was so good! Normandie, I loved it, the entire story! :-)
Sandy C chapter 22 . 1/24/2002
That was so sweet of you to think of your reviewers!I hope there will be a seqeul soon. Maybe it could be about Wilton's children going to Hogwarts and find adventures there or have an encounter with Voldemort. Your story was the best I ever read. I hope you keep up the great work!
114 | Page 1 2 3 4 .. Last Next »