What about Lily? But great stuff!

This touched my heart, I mean it actually made me cry. It is so beautiful! All the similarities you pointed out, and the impact that played on her life, it is just amazing! I loved it deeply!

Aw! Loved it! :D

well written, to the point, very dmotional and i absolutely loved it!

-Dramionelvr

That was so sweet i loved that side of her. You can actually write you know that.

Ooh, nice fic!

Love it! It's very well done!

Great... I got a bit teary at the end... well done!

PS I read you profile and I loved 'the hugs' part and I totally agree with you with the uncanon coupled. Totally.

Great story... Yeah, I would imagine that McGonagall would remember the seven...

~Ginerva Potter~

This was quite enjoyable. I don't see much with McGonagall- and even less so with the quality work, but I have to say that you did an excellent job.

I noticed that you were on Sivler Weasley's favorite's list, and since SW is absolutely amazing I had to come here because I expected the same quality.

And you're proving yourself quite well.

Here's to the Deathly Hallows and to insomnia!

Aw! Cute! I liked how you kept putting in the "she has been at Hogwarts a long, long time." Clever.

Overall: fantastic!

-Cady

This may seem a strange word to describe this fic, but I find it simply characterisation, the descriptions, every little thing was perfect, congratulations.

Wow. I loved it, especially the last line! That was awesome. Well done, you did an excellent job of capturing McGonagall's persona - which is hard to do.

What a wonderful fic...going in my favs for sure. You really captured McGonagall, and did a wonderful job w/ her!

Beautiful and perfect. Can't think of anything to say really.