beautiful!

This is just brilliant!

I love this! keep up the good work :)

Lovely!

so sweet a story.

Very sweet. Poor Maglor... This piece was incredibly well written and I really enjoyed it. The song was perfect for the last Feanorian. Well done.

Wow this was very beautiful and well written.

So fascinating. What an interesting fate for Maglor. Love it.

That was strange. Well done, though.

I wonder what Luna would have to say to him later in her life? And I'm surprised that Maglor didn't see anything deeper in Luna; she always seemed ethereal and saintly to me, perhaps protected by a higher power.

Thanks for the story.

Tom A.

I'm speechless. It's amazing. It's so simple but...amazing. I think it captures Maglor's sadness and loneliness really well, and it's so simple and believable too. I can't help but love both of them in this. Luna is so...herself. And I can't help but think this is the only bit of kindness Maglor will ever get D: It's wonderful though

Cute!

Luna was cute!

She is very kind!

I love Maglor!

Thanks for the story!

It was peaceful!

I never would have that of the premise for this story. I think it's very interesting that of all the Tolkien characters you picked Maglor... kudos for going out and doing something comepletely original. I loved this this piece. What an interesting idea, that the Elves that remained just faded away. Poor Maglor! I bet he wouldn't have been very welcome in the West. Good job blending these two canons. I hope you write more stories like this.

Just found this story. You wrote Luna well. I also liked Maglor.

Very nice.

As for the title, Twin Peaks?

This fic is awesome! I especially loved Maglor's reaction to Crumple-Horned Snorkacks. *grin* You've got Luna down perfectly, too, and the idea behind this is very amusing- Spirits of Fire, indeed... ((One little concrit: “That does not sound too unlike a Spirits of Fire” I think you meant a 'Spirit'.)) Once again, great story.