:D I loved this story! Sirius/Remus is one of my favorite pairings, and you wrote it beautifully! Well done! :) Good luck with future stories!

Oh...This was so funny and so sweet ! I liked it !

This is truly lovely... well done *gives big hug*

I am incredibly proud of you. (not that I even know you, I don't think, but slash is very good.) I liked the characterization, and how Remus was convinced he was hallucinating. And how it was light but not fluffy.

aw... How cute was that! Very. I love Sirius/Lupin. They're so cute toegther. Wow. That story was so fuzzy. m fuzzy! Cute and fuzzy. Yes, very good.

I just read this and oh wow, it's so pretty. And I liked the way you depicted James-him reading the magazine while acting cool and nonchalant-priceless. SO adorable!

This was not your first HP fanfic, no less your first slashie-you have got to be pulling my leg! I've read so many great R/S fics. This one is right up there with the tres great ones! Very descriptive, and Remmy's emotions were right on track.

If I knew you I would hug you very hard for writing this! You are the BEST.

So cute!

how adorable!

love

TJP

cool! keep on writing!

Okay, first up, i'm still moderately new to the fandom (S/R fics anyway), but i've read a lot of Remus/Sirius fics thus far and this is the first i've reviewed, because it's the first i've found that i really thoroughly enjoyed in its entirity.
The characters were believeable, enjoyable, the situations were entertaining, the plot was enjoyable, your writing was absolutely fantastic, style, tone, description, emotion, everything. I absolutely adored this fic.
Brilliant job with this, i think it's fantastic. I'll definitley read more if you decide to write more Sirius/Remus fics ... though i can relate to the reluctance to write a fic in the HP fandom (i have ideas bugging me too, but i'm trying to resist the urge to give in ;)
This story will be on my faves so i can read it over again continually.
Laters
~Vialana

That was AWESOME. I loved that, though the end didn't really compare to the rest, their reactions were a bit unrealistic, but aside from that I loved it. Great story!

Congrats for writing ur first HP fic. And how good it is! Haha.

Splendidly done! I give it 8!
Uozumi

Definitely impressive, for a first slash fic. Very cute, and I thought you managed to keep the boys in character remarkably well. And I really like that it was long. I'll be putting it on my favorites list, and I hope you write more R/S soon.