| Reviews for It's Not Just A Stick: A Wand Crafter's Story |
|---|
HP.HG. fan forever chapter 12 . 7/30 As AU's go this is the best I have read. Harry and Hermione are close and probably headed for romance later but they are not joined at the hip like so many others have them appear. Keepup the good work. |
bones71 chapter 12 . 7/29 This is a brilliant story loved the vision of Luna dancing with the Faries. Laughed at Harry wandering around looking for the Centaurs that's just typical Harry for you. Wow you are dedicated when you write looking up that law must have been time consuming. Looking forward to reading Draco etc going into the muggle world can just imagine it their poop heads will explode. |
Fast Frank chapter 12 . 7/25 So much fun! Love those Goblins! I foresee more frustration for Albus. |
Guest chapter 12 . 7/25 Lovely read, thank you |
Guest chapter 12 . 7/24 Hm, Harry and Hermione are prodigies. Not that I oppose but be careful not to turn them to Mary Sues. Looking forward to when his classmates come over to visit. |
Helene Nightfire chapter 4 . 7/26 Love your story so far! Thanks for your work on it and sharing the results. The only thing I would change is the telescope purchasing comments. I would think with a 7 year mandatory astronomy class you would see lots of telescope tinkering. Some common enchantments available for a standard student telescope would include space expansion charms applied to the interior of the telescope to accommodate a magically controlled perfectly smooth reflective surface of Goblin Silver for the high end and common silver or even a spelled smooth water surface for condensing light. Why search the skies when with an integral Point Me spell you could purchase a palm sized telescope that would let you count the rings of Saturn and see magical life on Mars! Maybe made of wand wood that needs matching to its owner for best results for searching out that comet or galaxy that you have an interest in, I suppose goblin silver might be the best at holding the spell to adjust the optics to give the best view. So used in high end telescopes... Ok. As you can tell I am passionate about this area of the classic shopping trip! I still maintain that a school that mandates 7 years of astronomy was probably founded by a space faring race that had forgotten its origins. On the other hand maybe it was mandated by a headmaster that was passionate about Astronomy and wanted to make the subject better understood. If this gives you ideas, feel free to use this in a future fic! I have no writing talent so it would be fun to see someone else use the idea. |
SoraGranger chapter 12 . 7/26 Wonderful chapter! Thank you for sharing. I love the banter between the professors haha. |
Dragonladysally chapter 12 . 7/26 I like hows this story is developing, but you wrote that Dumbledore cast a spell on the Dursly household, how did they break they break that curse/spell? a little back story on that would be something |
KTMac66 chapter 12 . 7/26 Love the prank and how it was done. Lots of fun and a timely warning not to fall into the trap the marauders did. |
Marcus Kyle chapter 12 . 7/26 yep, you're right Bumble something must be done, like stopping meddling in others lives or better going into retirement in a south pacific ocean deserted island. If the illegal guardian thing goes through then the Plans will even fall on the wayside... and all the monies, artefacts and stuff taken will be reclaimed with extreme Goblin prejudice. |
MissMuseOnline chapter 12 . 7/25 I’ve been reading so many in-progress Harry Potter fanfictions that I’ve forgotten what the timeline of this one is. Is this just before the Christmas holidays, or is it just before the summer holidays? I remember everything else about it though, so that’s good for me |
geekymom chapter 12 . 7/25 Fabulous chapter! |
Araytigre chapter 12 . 7/25 Always fun to see Gred and Forge pranked, lol, it keeps them humble, and on their toes! I like the Wand that Harry made for Luna, and I know that She will too. It will be interesting to see what Ollivander has to say concerning his questions. I can't wait to see Amelia's reaction to what they found out about Sirius, and his utter lack of a Trial. It would appear that Greg and Vince are More Slytherin than anyone knew! Thank You. TTFN |
csheila chapter 12 . 7/25 Love it. You build so many interesting worlds. The bit with the Goblins was great. After awhile you may want to lay off Twins. Though accelerating Hermione’s education is good outcome. |
LillianAsterPotter chapter 12 . 7/25 Where's the rest? |