i'm voting for any of the brothers honestly haha

i'm guessing she's a witch/vampire hybrid? if her body is new, could she have turned into a new creature? hmm that doesn't sound right. When I saw Shay, I thought perhaps an Aswang as she's half Filipino but i'm assuming she's the same creature she was when katherine's sister.

i wonder what she'll think, seeing her sister in an entirely new body?

Love your idea. Quite interresting. Just because i would love to See it im going to vote Rebekah/Lettie as a pairing. I know you said you would probably Use one of the boys, but a Girl can hope. ;) Hope you will Update soo!

I'm down for Kol/LettieLiliya and Klaus/LettieLiliya. But I'd really love Kol/Lettie/Klaus because unlike everyone else Kol and Nik would be perfectly capable of being in love with the same woman and sharing her. And decent poly fics are so rare. Usually they just make it all about the sex instead of how two people can complete parts of the third in a way one can't. If you can write a decent poly ship then please do Nik/Lettie/Kol but if you can't then either Kol/Lettie or Nik/Lettie are more than fine.
I'm very much against Elijah/Lettie... mostly because he had and sorta still has a huge thing for Katherine and falling for her sister would not make much sense. And also because there's plenty of Elijah/OC fics. Plus Lettie seems far too vibrant of a character to be drawn to someone like Elijah. To me the only person who's truly fitted with Elijah is Elena. Their personalities would mesh together so well... maybe Camille too.
As for Damon... just no. He's literally been with every girl or every girl has had a thing for him and he always screws them over for Elena so Lettie would just end up playing second fiddle to Elena and even if you wrote Damon getting over Elena he's still gonna be all weird over her. 90% of Damon's character is all about his love and obsession for Elena.
Wow okay this is so freaking long anyways Lettie's love interest hopefully will be both Kol and Nik or either one and if not them then maybe my baby Kai Parker.

I love shay Mitchell! I’ve thought about using her in my own stories !

Oh wow! I am loving this so far and I am so excited to read more!

Love this so far! I could see her going really well with Klaus, Kol, or Elijah honestly lol