Reviews for Gladiator
Diarona chapter 5 . 7/4
Yeah, I know ... you finished this over a year ago, but I just found it. Read it. Loved it. Legolas with the elven version of PTSD, and fortunately, surrounded by those best able to deal with it. Mix in the grandfather he never knew and finally, add his formidable father and ... well ... would be interesting to see where they all three go from here.

Very well done! Thank you.
ForestWren chapter 5 . 10/9/2019
Awww... This is awesome! Thank you for writing this amazing story!
Foxy-Floof chapter 5 . 9/14/2019
Awwww... This is hilariously domestic and yet amazing.

I like the idea of a story that talks about what happens AFTER Middle Earth...

And elves are probably really interesting that way, if only because they live so long, and are reborn again and again.
Guest chapter 2 . 8/15/2019
Illiterate. And your Elf names are godawful.
OdeFromParis chapter 5 . 7/7/2019
What a wonderful development ! I really love your story.
KimicThranduilion chapter 5 . 5/13/2019
Aah such a lovely family reunion. I'm so glad. Loved this - a very interesting first meet. Great work
Guest chapter 1 . 3/23/2019
oh, the DRAMA. NICE
amyboomerang chapter 5 . 2/24/2019
Aww, this was a sweet story. I am secretly happy we didn't have to have a scene with Legolas after Gimli's death. I have always preferred the uncanonical approach to the Fellowship, where if nothing else after they have gone to Mandos' halls they are let out in Valinor... It is so sad to see Gimli get old and frail.

I somehow think having all three of these strong personalities together may turn into a chance for complete chaos.

Thanks for writing! I very much enjoyed it. :)
pandorias chapter 5 . 2/24/2019
Oh I love this story! It was amazing, truly, and so much fun to read :)
It's really sad it's already finished :( Do you think there'll be another story or oneshot that plays after Gladiator? I'd love to read more about the life-to-come from Legolas, Thranduil and Oropher together in their home!
Starfox500 chapter 5 . 2/22/2019
I really loved this. From Oropher first noticing Legolas to the fight with Oropher's friend and him finally discovering that Legolas is his grandson. I'm glad that they managed to build a good relationship and that Oropher came to really care about Legolas. His mad dash to his house at being told that there was an emergy was nicely done.

I'm glad that Thranduil finally arrived and the three of them are together.
Alku04 chapter 5 . 2/21/2019
I absolutely loved this story! Thank you for sharing!
brankel1 chapter 5 . 2/21/2019
Totally amazing.
earthdragon chapter 5 . 2/21/2019
So good to see Thranduil finally in Aman. That was a beautiful reunion with his father. A lovely way to round this story off.
krakow chapter 5 . 2/21/2019
Funny and touching story, thanks for writing! The affection between all three is well-earned, and I liked the descriptions of the Valinor elves' various reactions to the presence of Legolas and Gimli. Also liked the inclusion of Legolas staying with Elrond and Celebrians family.

The absence of Thranduil and Orophers wives (even in characters thoughts) here feels a bit odd to me. In the books they're never mentioned by name, which makes their inclusion harder as you always have to introduce OCs. I think it's because I've recently read the story by Mirrordance giving Legolas a convincing mother figure who intentionally is never named, which has given me additional thoughts on this.

I always felt like in Valinor absolute thousands of slain Mirkwood elves must be gathered, all the warriors & villagers who died over the years. In your story they apparently haven't made a new Mirkwood 2.0 of their own yet, maybe they integrated into the exisiting realms?
Sophie Michard chapter 5 . 2/21/2019
Things getting better between grand-father and grand-son... and POUM ! Thranduil comes to Valinor at last !
Nice meeting, finally the speech was useless, they just needed to be in each other arms again. ;)
90 | Page 1 2 3 4 .. Last Next »