Do both keep writing this one and posting as you get them but also you can repost it as a complete and finished edited piece in the end we’re a good sounding board

I think just rewrite the story in a new web page. Say that this needs more work to be better and go try again, sure you'll lose Favs and Follows at first but this can be a fresh new start.
You can also try to just rewrite each chapter to be better and slowly release them, but you risk continuity breaks while you fix it.
Either way glad to see you didn't abandon this story just yet. Good luck on everything! :D

I have no idea what I just read. I have no frame of reference for the characters. I'm guessing that with the mention of centuries of age and Sire that Vampires are involved but that's it. Now the writer has written him/herself into a corner and can't write their way out so they are rewriting the whole thing from chapter 1, and their moving on to other works.

If you don't have the whole novel in your head from the start, don't write a Serialized story.
If you are not flexible and creative enough to, per chapter, write a Serialized story, write a novel
If you're not willing to storyboard out all the major and minor plot points and scenes before hand and use all the other tips, tricks, and tools... your odds of finishing a novel are very poor

You have the language and grammar skills, now you need to learn the other skills to write a story.
Just because you can drive nails with a hammer and cut wood with a saw doesn't mean you are ready to build a house.

As someone who's seen every option you've listed, here's what I will say: I only see fics get deleted if the author feels shame of some sort about it and has no wish to look at it any longer. Those that reupdate and edit chapter by chapter generally do that because they dont wish to lose reviews, but it's also more of; the want to update their writing style and a chunk of the plot. You could close the fic and start posting the update version chapter by chapter; this way you dont lose any of what you've made, and still have your old fic to both look back at and to please your readers by leaving the fic they found first for both nostalgia and new readers.

Or- you could post the updated work at a later date once you've caught back up. Here's the thing about the last two options: the first one will give you reviews, which can also help you with upcoming chapters and may provide a source of drive/encouragement and maybe even new ideas on how to better your fic. The 2nd will require you to motivate yourself and have limited feedback- if you have a beta.

Hope this helps with your choice!

If you like to have comments as you post your revisions, it makes sense to post a new story as the rewrite and mark this story as being revised. That way as you finish chapters and post them, the reviews will all be pertinent to the new story line.

Thanks for sharing your work!

The last question really scared me. If you "wait 5 years and publish then" then you'd loose a lot of current readers. About every 1 or 1 1/2 years I go through my subscribed list and delete majority of stories that's not been updated in over a year. In my experience, 90-95% of stories that laid stagnant for a year are never updated again. Maybe 1 story in 50 that I read would update after a year's hiatus.

My suggestions are
1. Leave this up but maybe alter title to "Altair -original" but add AN that you're redo-ing the story and will update it as new story.
2. update chapters as you go but add 'Update" or "Updated" to either the chapter's name or in a AN at top of chapter.
Frankly ch.1 sounds like less hassle.

Have you updated anything on this yet. I just started rereading this story 2 days ago but haven't gotten far, just to chapter 6.

Leave the story how it is

I'd say leave this one as is for posterity, and post the rewrite as a new story.

Rewrite as a new document

I would prefer it if you would post the rewrite as a new story

I think that when the author of a story wants to re-write their story I prefer they just start a new one, and leave the original one up. That way people who like the 1st version can read it even if it's not continued. What ever you decide I will keep an open mind and continue reading your story as I really enjoy it.

Hmmm, Well i like the story as it is, but Rewritten Version are good. I think you should Update this Story with the rewrite and post the old Version as a new story, or Post it as a new story and keep this one up.

How Diffrent is the Newer Version, ie Calio is a creature, or Calio more BAMF?

Honestly dont care what you do, im looking forward to it.

Lol, the gong crash was jarring, as was the realization that there is currently no more to read! Aaahh.

Well done. Totally enjoying your story. Brilliant.

Oh man that festival sounds so intriguing. This story is still by far one of my faves and I wonder how many of the students from Hogwarts will have the same feeling as Terry is now experiencing. I am curious if those Hedghogs will be seen again by them as well especially since they took such a liking to Justin. Luna and Azzie seem to really being enjoying themselves and I am curious about how the research in Azzie's magic will go. I can't wait to see how this backfires on the British Ministry and Dumbledore.

xxxxx Kudos xxxxx : )