AAAAAAAH I LOVE IT ALREADY! I’m so excited for this! Also I hope you know that if Dwalin, Kili, Bilbo or Legolas get seriously hurt, maimed, disfigured or killed I will actually die. That got a lot darker than I meant it to but the point still stands! Lol. I’m so excited for what you have in store for us and I wish you the best of luck! Your writing style is amazing and the way you balance angst, humor and seriousness is something to envy in my opinion!

Plz update! Love this story sooo much that I read it twice.

Love the interactions. Thranduil playful is a marvel to see...I wish Bilbo would keep the thing in a warded pouch still. No skin contact!

Please update!

Hi, I love this story so so much. I binged your last book and this one. I know it's been a while, but I can't wait for the next update!

awesome...please update soon.

Please update this story! It’s so good!

This is the best lotr story I’ve ever read! I cannot wait for an update!

Where's the next chapter? I need to know what happens next.

Is Nocturne as beautiful as Sleepsong?

Wait, who is Estel? It can't be Aragon because he had rode with the horse lord who's coming with Bilbo so he can't be the human child in Elrond's house now.
Please don't tell me that you've dropped this story , by the date of the last update it's been nearly a year since you last added a chapter.
I'll be waiting for the next chapter.

Oh ... I realized that it might be a possibility when you wrote that Bilbo was joined by 3 hobbits, but now I am seeing so many more connections of where you're using an older generation in place of their younger kin.
The heir to the steward of Gondor, was he an older brother to Denathor?

I was wondering who old Tom was when I remembered Tom Bombadil , am I right?

Estel, isnt that one of the names that Aragon goes by?

Ah , so that's what the journey he taking is.