Definitely Her, Or Maybe It's Her

Summary: Based off the film Definitely, Maybe. Finn Hudson's daughter Charlotte (Charlie) asks him about who her mom is. Will it be Quinn, Santana or Rachel? Mulitchapter story- hopefully story is better than summary.

Disclaimer: I don't own the film Definitely, Maybe or Glee. All rights go to owners- RIB and Universal.

Chapter 1: Tell Me The Story

If someone had told me when I was in high school that in 20 years time I would have an 11 year old daughter and be a single dad I would have laughed. But here I am. And I wouldn't change a thing. And you're probably wondering who I am. Finn Hudson, 35 years old, I own a music store in Manhattan. I thought I had my life all figured out and I was wrong.

My daughter Charlotte Maria Hudson is the best thing that ever happened to me. But I should've know that I couldn't hold off the questions with "Your mom loved me and you sweetie but we wanted different things" forever. And so when I picked Charlie up from school the inevitable happened. She asked about her mom. "Dad I think it's time you tell me the story of you and mom". "Charlie we've talked about this. You're too young to hear all the sordid details of my love life". She looks up at me with her pleading puppy eyes and says "Dad, it's a girls right to know who her mom is. Every other girl my age does. I want to know who she is. I have a right to know who she is. Please Dad. If you tell me the story then I might understand". "Understand what honey?" I ask her. "Why she left me" Charlie says and looks down at her shoes. I drive home in complete silence.

When we get inside and Charlie and I sit down for dinner I finally break the awkward silence between us. "Ok Charlie" I say. "Ok what?" she says. "I'm going to tell you the story of me and your mother. But I'm not going to tell you which one of the women in the story is your mom. You have to figure it out for yourself" I say. "I like it, it's like a mystery!" Charlie says jumping up and down in excitement. "Ok then. Are you ready to hear the story of me and your mom?" I ask. She gives me her sarcastic look and says "I've been waiting 11 years Dad. I think I'm just about ready to know". "No need to be snarky" I say wagging my finger jokingly at Charlie. "Can I ask you a question first?" she says. "Anything you like honey" I say. "Do I look like her? My mom I mean?" she says. I look at my daughter with her brunette curls, long lashes and big brown eyes and I say "You look just like her". She smiles and I start the story. "I met your mom in high school. I had three girlfriends in high school. And one of those girls is your mom".

"So who were the three girls?" Charlie asked me. I tell her to wait in the living room of the apartment and bring out my high school yearbook from senior year. I open it to the page of the glee club photo. "This is Quinn, Santana and Rachel. They were the three girls that I dated during high school" I say. "Wait" Charlie says and runs back to get some paper. "If I'm going to work out who my mom is I'm going to need to write down clues". She nods at me to continue. "So the first one I met was Quinn. It was my freshman year of high school and…."

It was my freshman year of high school. I tried to walk down the halls of my new school McKinley High like I owned it but the truth was I was a nobody. At least until I made Quarterback then I would rule the school.

"Daddy were you always obsessed with being popular. You always told me that being popular didn't matter, you should do what you love" Charlie says to me.

"Until I joined glee club yeah I was obsessed with popularity. But glee helped me realise that it wasn't everything. Now do you want me to tell you more of the story?" I ask.

"Yes please daddy" she says.

So as I was walking through the halls of McKinley High I stopped to notice the hot chicks that seemed to fill the school. One girl particularly caught my eye. She was a petite, blonde with her hair in a high ponytail. I tried to look at her in a way that made it look like I wasn't looking but she turned and walked towards me. "Hey, you a freshman too huh?" she asked. "Yeah. I'm Finn Hudson. And you are?" I ask. "Incredibly hot and available" she says flicking the end of her ponytail and I have to stop myself from licking my lips. I see the twinkle in her eye and we both laugh. "Seriously though, what's your name?" I ask. "I'm Quinn Fabray" she says. "Okay this is going to sound a bit awkward seeing as how we just met….." I start to say but then I feel Quinn's finger on my lips. She takes a pen out of her bag and writes something on my arm. "My number. You could call me if you like" she says. "Maybe I will" I say and I watch as Quinn walks away.

"So how long was Quinn around?" Charlie asks me. "I dated Quinn through the entirety of my freshman year and most of my sophomore year" I tell Charlie. "So did you love her?" Charlie asks me. "At that point I thought I did. But then Quinn did something I could never forgive". "What did she do Dad?" Charlie asks me. I look up at the clock and see that it's late. "Honey it's late you need to go to bed". "No I want to know what Quinn did to you" she says. "No Charlie you need to go to bed". She starts to walk towards her room but turns around "One last question Dad" she says and I look at her inquiringly. "Did she break your heart?" she asks me. "They all did. At some point all three of the women in this story broke my heart" I say.

A/N: Okay so I'm going to work this like I did with my last story- I'd really like your input for where you want this story to go- e.g. what did Quinn do to Finn (it doesn't necessarily have to be the same as in the show)- so just leave suggestions in your reviews and they'll make it into the story.

Review?