A/N: and so, we meet again! :) ok, so this is a new story and I know I haven't updated You Found Me, so maybe I shouldn't be posting a new story, but this was running and running in circles in my mind and it was driving me CRAZY PEOPLE! and I'm working on the new chapter of You Found Me, but since it's about to end, it has to be perfect so hang in there.

Now, here's the thing. What if Puck didn't try to make the football team join Glee and didn't get his ass kicked and didn't get Lauren to join Glee? Instead this is the deal: Puck, Finn, Mike and Matt (yeah, so I hated that he left, so sue me) had a really close friend growing up. But she left two years ago, because she moved with her family. Well, now she's back and she might be just perfect for Glee Club.

Now, here's the twist. I don't know who this girl is. You get to decide. My original idea was to use a totally new character for this girl. But idk if, well, readers like new characters and well since all of my stories are based on what my readers want (that means you) you get to decide if the new girl is a new character (if she is, you will learn her name in the next chapter) or if the new girl's name is Rachel Berry. (any resemblance to You Found Me is purely coincidental ) I'm kidding, is totally different! so you decide. The thing is, whoever the new girl is, she's totally different from Rachel, she's a little bit like the girl version of Puck. So you be the judges! enjoy - moony

Disclaimer: I don't own Glee, or We The Kings for that matter.

"All I can say is that I didn't steal that soda machine, and if I did, I didn't do it alone" Puck defended himself in Mr. Schue's office.

"Ok, I'm going to ignore that because if I didn't I would be left with ten people in Glee Club and if you remember that's two less than what the Rule Book says" Mr. Schue told him.

"I'm not big on reading rulebooks. Actually, I'm not big on reading" Puck told him.

"Kurt's gone and he's not coming back. We need a new member. Now, I want you to use your madness to recruit a new member. Glee needs you to be its ambassador" Mr. Schue told him.

"More like it's am-badass-ador" Puck said smirking.

"He said what?" Matt asked him on the hallway.

"He told me to look for a new member for Glee" Puck told him.

"How the hell are you gonna do that?" Mike asked him.

"I don't know, but you're gonna help me" he told them.

"Hey guys" Finn said coming to them. "We're still on for tonight right?" he said a little sad.

"Of course we're still on" Mike told him a little annoyed. "It's her birthday!"

"Yeah, we always go there for her birthday" Matt told him.

"I know. I just didn't want you to forget it" Finn told them. Puck was silent.

"Ok, so see you guys at eight" Mike said as they went they're separate ways.

"I can't believe it's been two years" Matt said sadly as they sat on the table of the bar.

"How do you-" Finn started. "Do you think she's like still the same?"

"Of course she's still the same" Matt said with a sad smile. "She wouldn't change for anyone" he said with a little chuckle.

"Can we not talk about it?" Puck asked a little upset. He didn't like to think about that. He didn't like to think about her.

"We all miss her dude" Mike told him.

"I know" he said annoyed. "Let's just think of someone who can join Glee! Sectionals are next week" he told them.

"No one is going to join Glee" Finn said. "Everyone hates it!"

"Hey, looks like there's a new band playing today" Matt told them looking at the band preparing on stage.

"Ladies and gentlemen, may I have your attention for a minute" a waitress said standing on stage. "Please give it up for We The Kings" she said excited and the whole bar started cheering for them.

"Hey everyone" Travis said in the microphone. "We're We The Kings and tonight we invited a really special friend to sing with us, and it's her birthday so you better cheer for her" he said laughing a little. "We hope you like it" he said smiling. [A/N: in case you don't know, Travis is the lead singer of We The Kings :)]

A girl started playing the guitar and she started singing along with Travis.

Brown eyes and lungs are filled up with smoke

Fast lives we're stuck in the undertow

But you know the places I wanna go

'Cause oh oh oh I've got a sickness

You've got the cure

You've got the spark I've been looking for

And I've got a plan

We walk out the door

You know you wanna just let go

It's time to roll down the windows

And sing it oh oh oh

We got all we need so here we go

Turn it up

It's five minutes to midnight

You're coming home with me tonight

I can't get enough

Shakin' me up

Turn it up, alright

At five minutes to midnight

We'll see our name in city lights

We'll make the clock stop

Make your heart drop

And come alive

We could pack up and leave all our things behind

No fact or fiction or storyline

'Cause I need you more than just for tonight

You're oh oh oh like air

I can't stop my breathing in

I'm weak and you are my medicine

I won't stop 'til I am under your skin

You know you wanna just let go

It's time to roll down the windows

And sing it oh oh oh

We got all we need so here we go

Turn it up

It's five minutes to midnight

You're coming home with me tonight

I can't get enough

Shakin' me up

Turn it up, alright

At five minutes to midnight

We'll see our name in city lights

We'll make the clock stop

Make your heart drop

And come alive

And when the clock strikes twelve

Will you find another boy to go kiss and tell?

'Cause you know I never will

I think we should strike a match

And we'll hold it to the wind to see how long it lasts

We could make the time stand still

Turn it up

It's five minutes to midnight

You're coming home with me tonight

I can't get enough

Shakin' me up

Turn it up, alright

At five minutes to midnight

We'll see our name in city lights

We'll make the clock stop

Make your heart drop (and come alive)

Turn it up

It's five minutes to midnight

Coming home with me tonight

I can't get enough

Shakin' me up

Turn it up, alright

At five minutes to midnight

We'll see our name in city lights

We'll make the clock stop

Make your heart drop

And come alive

When the song finished everyone started cheering for them. Everyone that is, but four boys sitting at a table with the most shocked looks on their faces.

"Did you guys see what I just saw?" Finn asked dumbly never taking his eyes off the girl on stage. The other three nodded looking at her too.

"It can't be… right?" Matt started.

"But it is" Mike interrupted him.

"It's her" Puck said. Out of the four, he had the most surprised look on his face.

A/N: song: Five Minutes to Midnight - Boys Like Girls (I just really love that song so.. yeah)

sorry is so short, but again, I kind of need your help to continue! please read and review and let me know who YOU think I should pair Puck with :) because yeah, she will be involved with Puck. if you have no idea what I'm talking about, read the A/N on the top! let me know what you think :)