Note: I don't own anything in the WWE, I wish I did though lol. I only own Michelle and Jen.
John sat in his room thinking about what had happened that day. He knew he had to keep Randy away from Shell. He saw the look in her eye whenever she was with Randy. John could tell that part of her still loved Randy and that scared him to know he could lose her. But then he couldn't take Shell away from her best friend. He was in one hell of a predicament.
Knock Knock
"Who the hell is that." John grumbled to himself while getting up to get the door. He opened it to find Shell on the other side
"Hey, Can we talk?" Shell asked slowly
"Yeah come in." He said and held the door open for her
XxxxxxX
Randy laid on his bed staring blankly at the T.V. But his mind was still on Shell. On why it took so long for him to realize that he loved her. Why did it have to be now? Why couldn't it have been before John came into the picture? A knock at the door drew him out of his thoughts. He got up to find Jen on the other side. She walked right in without saying anything.
"Well hi to you too." Randy said sarcastically
"What are you up to Randall Keith Orton? And don't lie to me because I know when you're lying." Jen asked getting right to the point
"What do you mean?"
"I mean with Shell. What the hell are you doing?
Randy sighed and laid back down on the bed. He didn't really want to get into this right now, but if he knew Jen like he though then she would force him to talk.
"I have no idea Jen." He began "I've always felt this way for Shell but I never wanted to say anything. I never wanted to make things weird between me and her. I have always cared for her as more than a friend but I didn't want to go any farther than that. I didn't want to end up hurting her. I've seen her cry so many times and I don't think I could stand knowing that I'd eventually be the reason she'd cry."
"Randy, you not admitting your feelings to her made her cry. She always thought she was never good enough or that she was ugly. You have no idea how many times she cried out of frustration. Or that night you guys slept together, That was hard on her because she thought she was finally getting somewhere with you"
"It makes no difference anyways now. She's with John and she's happy, that's what matters." Randy said trying to end the discussion.
"No Randy, It does make a difference now. She still wants you but now its even worse because of John. Why couldn't you have admitted your feelings before? Now someone is bound to get hurt, whether its you or John. John cares for her, we both know that."
"I know that. I just don't know what to do." Randy honestly told her.
XxxxxxX
Meanwhile in John's room...
"Im glad you stopped by actually. I do want to talk to you about something. But you can go first on what you wanted to talk about." John told her
"No you go ahead, what I have to say can wait." Shell said not wanting to have to talk about it.
"Alright well its about Randy."
"Oh really? Well that's what I wanted to talk to you about too." Shell said, now wondering what John could possibly have to say about it.
"I heard you guys talking in the hallway. I heard him say he loved you. I want to know, Do you love him?"
"John...he's my best friend."
"That's not answering the question."
"Fine. I have no idea if I do or not. But Im with you John so he doesn't matter." Shell said while grabbing John's hand
"I don't want you around him anymore Shell." John said trying to hold in the frustration.
"Im sorry, I don't think I heard you right?" Shell said surprised at what he just told her.
"I said, I don't want you to hang out with him anymore."
" What the hell John? What gives you the right to say that!? You can't tell me who I can and cannot hang out with. Im going to hang out with my best friend whether or not you approve of it" Jen said dropping his hand and standing up
"Im trying to prevent you from making a mistake that could screw up our relationship!"
"No you're trying to be a control freak and Im not going to stand here and take it. I think the only mistake I made was getting into this relationship with you." Shell replied coldly
"Fine if you're going to be like that than leave and go run off to Randy!" John yelled
"You know what? I will" Shell yelled back and stormed out of the room, slamming the door behind her. And headed right for Randy's room of course.
John groaned in frustration knowing that he probably just did her and Randy a favor by just letting her walk out of the room.
XxxxxxX
"Im just going to wait this out and hopefully it'll blow over." Randy told her
"Im glad I at least got to talk to you about this. Id better go though, I have a date with Carlito later and I don't really want to be late." She said staring at the clock that read 9:30
"Alright Ill see ya later." He said pulling his cousin into a hug. Jen walked out of the room and Randy closed the door behind her. A few minutes later there was a knock at the door. Randy figured it was Jen again and she probably had forgot something. He opened it to find a very pissed off Shell instead.
"Hey Shell what's going on?" He asked worried
Shell pushed him inside of the room and immediately started kissing him.
Randy was surprised at this at first but he didn't want to stop her because he was enjoying it way too much. Finally he thought of what would happen if John found out and pulled back.
"Shell what about John?"
"Were over." She said pushing Randy onto the bed and then started kissing him again.
Again he stopped her. " What do you mean over?"
"I went over there to talk, he said he didn't want me to hang around with you anymore and I basically told him to screw off and I ended it right there."
Knowing that was enough for Randy. He wanted Shell more than anything right now.
"Be my girl then" Randy asked hopefully
Shell smiled at him. Finally she was getting what she wanted. To be with Randy..
"Its about time Orton." She said before she kissed him
"Is that a yes?"
"Thats a hell yes." She told him and then started kissing him again. Slowly things started heating up more and more. A couple minutes later they were tugging at each others clothes. They both had wanted this for so long...
Okay So I know it took forever for me to update and Im REALLY sorry about that. I've been super busy over summer and school getting out and everything. I have the next chapter written though and It should be up soon too
And you guys are gonna hate me for putting her with Randy hehe...