Hi everyone! This is my first story on here so I'm really nervous. I know this is a weird pairing, I think there is only one other story on her right now with this pairing, but they have such great chemistry on the CW shows that I thought this would be a fun pairing in Glee as well. Please let me know what you think of the story, I would really appreciate reviews. If you have concerns let me know.

Marley POV

Marley trailed behind the rest of Glee club, looking down at her shoes. They were at a nightclub in Westerville where Dalton Academy was because of an invite from Blaine's friends in the Warblers.

She didn't want to be here, but they hadn't given her much of a choice. So now, here she was in a dress and heels that she hated, painted up with makeup that made her feel cheap and with jewelry that she didn't even know she owned. The only part of her outfit that was her own was the black shimmering nail polish.

Kitty swore that she looked hot, but Marley tried not to listen too much. Kitty tended to mock her when she thought that Marley wasn't paying attention.

A girl who worried about much less then her would have changed her mind when they encountered the Warblers. Their eyes took her in like starving men who haven't seen a girl in years. It was flattering and creepy at the same time.

However, one man caught her attention immediately.

Sebastian Smythe was legend in McKinley because of the slushy incident, which everyone found out after the fact, was not his fault. He was still known as a dick.

Marley's breath stilled in her throat as her blue eyes met his green ones. He smiled charmingly at her as they shook hands. She smiled patiently and the first chance that she had, she got away from the group. She needed a drink.

She got to the bar and sat on one of the stools while she waited for her drink. She looked at her reflection in the glass mosaic along the wall and then noticed the green-eyed devil walking up behind her.

Sebastian POV

Sebastian had noticed her the moment she walked into the club and now that he looked at her as she sat at the bar, he couldn't help but be drawn in by her appearance.

The dress she had on was a light blue that complimented her lightly tanned skin and fit her like a second skin. The skirt barely coming to mid-thigh and the halter-top leaving her back bare while the plunging neckline went almost to her navel. The strappy blue and grey heels that she had made her legs seem impossibly long, the blue topaz flower necklace brought the right amount of sparkle, and the quick brush of blue eyeliner made her eyes pop.

He watched her worry her pink bottom lip with her teeth as she fiddled with her blue flower earring.

Walking up, he leaned against the bar, giving his order as the bartender set a drink in front of the girl.

"Wow, I wouldn't have figured you for a whiskey girl," He said in surprise.

"Well, I was thinking I needed something strong to make it through this night," She replied and downed the shot in one gulp, her nose crinkling adorably.

That was admirable in his opinion, but he noticed her tugging at the skirt of her dress obviously wishing it was longer. "You don't seem very comfortable," He commented, as two shots of tequila were set in front of him. He downed one and pushed the other over to her.

Marley looked at him, raising an eyebrow. "How charming," She said. "Do you always want to make people feel as unattractive as possible?"

"I didn't say you weren't hot," He said, eyes raking over her appreciatively. "You just don't seem to understand your own appeal to the guys here,"

"I thought you were gay?" She replied confused taking her shot.

"Gay?" He said amused. "No, that's just something I did to get under Kurt's skin,"

Marley raised an eyebrow again and he found it rather attractive.

"Want to dance?" It was asked as a question, but he took her hand before she could reply and led her onto the dance floor.

Marley POV

Trying to remember how to breathe right, Marley let the beat of the music slip into her brain. She allowed her body to work without thought and soon she and Sebastian were attracting more than just some attention as they battled back and forth, trying to one up the other and getting closer and closer.

As the song ended, Marley had a smile on her face and she was feeling more relaxed. She saw Sebastian grin as he saw the smile on her face.

Marley was pulled away from him to dance with Blaine, Kitty and Unique, Jake, Ryder, and a few of the Warblers but she always saw Sebastian during those dances. Watching her even as he danced.

At around 1:00am Marley found herself back in Sebastian's arms. Instead of their earlier playfulness, they danced slowly, their clothes were the only thing separating them as they pressed together.

Her fingers threaded through his hair as he pulled her tighter against him.

"Let's get out of here," He whispered in her ear.

Marley glanced around her and noticed that everyone else was either too drunk or too preoccupied with sucking face with someone else to notice her and Sebastian. "Let's go," She replied breathily.

He led her out of the club and into the cold night air. Marley shivered as the cold wind bit in to her overheated skin. Sebastian didn't have a jacket with him so he rushed her over to his car.

They jumped into the black SUV and Sebastian turned on the heater, reaching in the back for his hoodie to give to her. Marley used the hoodie to cover her legs and she pressed her fingers to the vent.

After a minute they both started to warm up again.

The cold wind had cleared her brain some and she realized how she had been acting with Sebastian, immediately feeling embarrassed. She glanced at him nervously out of the corner of her eye and saw him shake his head as if to clear his thoughts. His green eyes were clear as they turned on to her.

Marley smoothed her hair nervously as she fidgeted.

Sebastian chuckled. "You really are innocent, aren't you?" He said amused.

Her cheeks flushed. She looked away from him.

"Look, you don't have to be nervous," He said leaning back in his seat. "I'm not expecting anything from you."

She turned back to him and saw he was sitting perfectly relaxed, watching her with an amused smirk. "How are you always so in control?" She asked finally.

He shrugged. "Practice," He said. "But it also takes feeling comfortable with yourself and ready for anything, that way you'll never be caught off guard."

"You make it sound so easy," She said.

"Marley," He said. "Let me ask you something. Who made you wear that dress?"

She furrowed her brow. "Kitty," She said.

Sebastian shook his head. "Wrong." He said. "No one can make you do anything. You put the dress on yourself and you came here to this club, and you danced with me and several other guys because it was fun. Not because someone made you."

She opened her mouth to protest but he held up his hand.

"Did 'Kitty' make you dance with me?" He asked.

"No," She said after a moment.

He raised an eyebrow. "Did you enjoy dancing with me?" He asked.

She furrowed her brows. "Yes," She admitted.

"How did you feel dancing tonight?" He asked.

She bit her low lip. "Free," She said after a moment.

Sebastian smiled. "Marley, you are an easy person for me to classify," He said. "You're a pleaser. Your whole life you've strived to make other people happy, but you need to do something just for yourself."

Sebastian POV

Sebastian watched as Marley blinked her big blue eyes at him, his words sinking in. She opened her mouth and then closed it again. He grinned and turned his eyes forward, knowing that he had won.

"And how would you classify yourself?" She asked suddenly.

He raised an eyebrow and turned his head slightly, so he could look at her. "What do you mean?" He asked.

"You said you would classify me as a 'pleaser' but what would you classify yourself as?" She asked.

He turned more to face her fully as his signature smirk crossed his lips. "I'm a pleaser too, but of a different variety." He said with a suggestive smile.

Marley blushed brightly but she held her ground. "Really?" She said. "What makes you think that you're all that?"

He grinned showing teeth now. "Well, I could show you," He said hand brushing lightly down her arm.

She shivered delicately but she seemed to be trying to push herself. "Let's see how much you can teach me," She purred moving closer, her lips just inches away from his.

His pulse leaped in excitement as he leaned a little closer to her. At the last minute, she pulled away, opening her door. She looked back at him with a 'follow me' look as she got out of the car.

Curiosity got the best of him and he turned the car off, jumping out to follow her. He entered the club after her to see her already moving on to the dance floor.

He smiled as he moved to follow, now very intrigued by this blue-eyed angel.