A/N: Hey everyone, Sofia2015 and I had a bet about my birthday and now that she has won, I promised her to make a story she wishes to happen. So she asked me to make and Alternate Story to "An Apprentice's Apology" where Cedric didn't forgive Sofia. So go easy on the reviews because this is my first Alternate Story! I think. This will be fun to work on. As for the question if I had enjoyed my birthday, well I did! Multi- chapter story

Sofia the First: How Could She

Chapter 1: the Sorcerer's Broken Heat

In Enchantia, peasants and royals were beginning to turn in for the night. It had been a long, tiresome day for everyone! Including the youngest princess of the kingdom. Sofia had caused a lot of trouble, about almost everyone was angry at her, but nobody could be more angry toward Sofia than Cedric!

The young girl had used magic without him being there next to her! She wasn't even having a lesson at that time. Yes, this did upset the sorcerer terribly; he thought she would be wise with her choices. Why didn't she use that wisdom she used to teach her friends and him! Now, it was thanks to her that Cedric was drowning his depression and anger in jelly beans.

Earlier, he had done nothing but cry. Not only was he angry towards her, he was upset that he wasn't able to get her amulet again. Why had she betrayed him? Before they had started her lessons he had given her rules and she had just broken the biggest one. What would she do next? If she did anything else that broke his rules, he would be a broken. shattered and a betrayed man.

The sorcerer was beginning to feel a special bond with Sofia but now that she had done something that had hurt him he was afraid things would go back to the ways they were before she came along. If he saw her again he'll remember she taken his heart and had broken it.

A familiar knock came to the door and Cedric began to growl under his breath. The sorcerer got yp from his desk, sat the bowl of jelly beans down and stomped toward the door having each step hit the floor with his furry.

When he saw the very princess he was angered at in front of him his anger grew even more. "What is it?" he asked in anger. Sofia looked up at him with fresh tears in her eyes. She could tell he was angry at her, it shown up when he spotted her.

"I came to apologize about my actions, I know shouldn't have used your copying spell. It was wrong." Sofia answered trying to wipe the tears away.

Cedric felt a sad and angry pang inside. Something in him kept telling him to forgive her but he had to ignore it for now. During his school days at Hexley Hall, the teacher had told them if they ever had an apprentice that disobeyed them, they were to be punished. Even his father had told him that.

The man had no choice but to follow through with this plan. If the princess was to learn her lesson, he'd have to punish her or else she would keep doing wrong. "I'm afraid sorry isn't going to cut it princess." He answered crossing his arms and turning around so he wouldn't have to look at her. His heart couldn't really take it, it was already broken, he wouldn't allow her to hurt him anymore. Even if it meant to return to his cold, mean ways and continue to try to find a way to swipe her amulet. So be it!

"What can I do to make it up to you?" Sofia asked as she looked down to the floor, His cold attitude was now breaking her heart! Not to mention he had used her title instead of her name, that had really hurt her. Didn't her friend ever hear of the word" Mercy"? Was he even her friend anymore?

"I'm afraid; we're going to have to take away your lessons until I know I can trust you again! What you did was pretty low, and school has taught me that an apprentice must be punished when they disobey their teacher." With nothing else to say he closed the door then sank to the floor and buried his head in his arms!

A/N: How was this? Writing this was breaking my heart! I never did a story with Sofia and Cedric in a bad situation like this. Anyways, I was going name this story "Gaining the Sorcerer's Trust" but that seemed pretty long for a title, so I just went with "How Could She" I liked that better. It sounds sadder and heart breaking. Well, please review!