Take the Bait Part 2:

Payment in Full

They both stirred to the sound of knocking on the front door. Lucy snuggled into Natsu's chest, murmuring against his neck, "Who the hell is that?" He just hummed in agreement, slowly stroking her hair. Then several hands pounded into the door, and Lucy registered worried tones drifting from the door. "What're they saying?" Natsu sighed, lifting himself from the bed. Lucy whimpered and stretched her hands out to him. "They're wondering where we are. They're all so damn nosy. They're threatening to break down the door if we don't answer." He started toward the door, but Lucy gasped. "Natsu! We're naked! If they come in they'll see and it won't be too hard to put the pieces together!" Natsu shrugged. "So what?" Lucy blushed. "So put some clothes on!" He grumbled but then started searching for his pants. "Wait. Where did my clothes even end up?" Both realizing that his clothes were laying about the apartment, and that there was lots of evidence to show their actions as well. Lucy surveyed her apartment, they had gone throughout each room. Tables were flipped over, things spewed across the floor, chairs overturned, and not to mention sticky white liquid almost everywhere. She stared at Natsu in horror. There's no way they could cover this up. He laughed at the expression on her face.

"I guess there's no hiding it then right? They'd find out eventually anyways." Natsu gave her an encouraging smile. Lucy sighed, he was right. Damn nosy people who cared. As she made her way to the door she grabbed the towel from yesterday fumbled in a heap near the couch and covered herself with it. Lucy unlocked the door and cracked it open, just so her face showed. She realized that was dumb, her lips were swollen and her hair was probably insanely crazy- and she felt some dried substance on the side of her face, probably in many more places than just there. She cracked a hesitant smile. "Uh, hi guys." Several people were outside her door: Levy, Erza, Gray, Wendy, Cana, Juvia, and even Gajeel. They all questioned her at once, Lucy only picked up bits and pieces, "Are you okay?" "haven't seen you since-" "just concerned" "you don't look good" "what's been going on" "we thought" "just making sure" Lucy held up a hand to silence them. Erza tried to open the door further, "Is Natsu with you? We haven't seen him all day either." Lucy kept the door in place, trying to think of an excuse. She was flustered, nothing coming out of her gapping mouth. Too much time was passing in silence, and they began having suspicious looks as they took in her appearance.

Suddenly she felt warm strong arms around her and saw everyone's face become blank as the door slowly opened to reveal the inside. Shit! There really was no way to hide it. Natsu's chin rested on her shoulder, she knew there would be a smug smirk plastered across his face. Her face flushed as everyone fit the pieces together. She could see the scene from their eyes: Lucy holding a towel around her, Natsu completely bare embracing her like a lover, and the damage and evidence of the apartment. "Damn." "No more love rival!" "I knew it. Like bunnies." "Oh my Mavis!" "Ku ku ku Lu-chan!" "Since when?" "Geehehe." Erza stared at them with a mix of horror and fascination on her face. Her face matched her hair as she took in the scene. Her mouth made motions, but no sounds came out. Natsu laughed, "You look like a fish Erza!" He stepped away from Lucy to avoid her elbow. Wendy screamed and covered her face, "KYA!" Lucy glared at him, "Natsu." She yanked the door in front of him so the others wouldn't be exposed to his nudity. He cackled and grabbed her waist from behind again. "As you can see we are busy. And just fine. Better than fine. Way way better than fine-" "Shut it Natsu!" He didn't have time to avoid the elbow that Lucy sent this time.

"Well we have some business to attend to so if you don't mind..." Natsu slammed the door in their faces and immediately discarded the towel around Lucy. He slammed her against the door and groped her- knowing the others were still there (besides Wendy who had ran away in embarrassment) leaning their ears against the door. Lucy cried out, "Ow! Natsu I still hurt from last night... Please let me rest some more..AH!" He had slipped his fingers into her, pressing her against the door, grinding into her butt. He kissed down her neck, his other hand frisking her breasts. She moaned loudly. She heard giggling and gasps. Lucy pounded her hands against the door, "Get the hell out of here you perverts!" Blatant laughter answered her, "You're the perverts!" "Yeah you sex monkeys!" "Oh wait 'til I tell the whole guild. This is gold." Lucy yelped as Natsu entered her roughly, already humping away. "Natsu! S-stop it they're r-right there- ngh!" She panted as he continued to slide into her. Suddenly he spun her around, hiking her legs up around his waist. He grunted as he slammed her back into the door, having better access from the front.

"Ahh!" She groaned as he filled her deeply. She sank her nails into his back, temporarily forgetting who was on the other side of the door as pleasure filled her. She was quickly reminded when she heard "Mavis! They're about to break the door down!" followed by snickers and "Won't that be a sight?" Her temper flared, "I said get out! You're ruining the mood!" Natsu thrusted again ending her order in a moan. "Haha! Doesn't sound like it Lucy!" Lucy cursed at them. "Oh fuck you!" They laughed again, "Better look in front of you- or behind you- because you aren't fucking any of us right now." Lucy's retort was cut off as Natsu captured her lips. Does having sex while others hear them a turn on to him?! "Hah, ah...hah.." She let out sex noises as he sent her against the door again and again and again. "AH! Natsu! Almost.. ah! Faster!" She had completely forgotten their audience as she neared her climax. She was enraptured with the man in front of her, pleasuring her.

Her screams and moans escalated. She howled out his name as her body clenched around him. She slumped against the door, letting the euphoric spasms wash over her. Natsu continued to collide into her. He grunted with effort, he thought maybe he could make her come again before he let go. Lucy happily let him go on. After a few more minutes, Lucy moaned loudly as her second climax neared. "Guh.. Lucy.. I don't know if I can..." "Just a bit more! Faster Natsu!" She helped him by bouncing up and down, using the door and her grip around his waist as leverage. Their moans rose. After a few thrusts they were both screaming each others' names.

Natsu rested against Lucy, their chests heaving against each other. "That'll never get old Luce." Lucy smiled up at him but was reminded of the other party when hoots and congratulatory whoops were sounding from the other side of the door. Her face flooded in embarrassment and anger, "Natsu what the hell!" It wasn't Natsu who answered. "Awe Lucy is that what you say after getting lucky? Give the guy a break!" Natsu suddenly lifted away from the door, Lucy still balanced on his hips. He flung the door open and everyone came tumbling into the room since they were leaning against it. Lucy screeched. "Kya! Natsu I'm naked! Get out! Get the hell out!" She tried covering herself and disentangling herself from Natsu. The others were staring at them, amazed at the scene. Natsu just pulled her closer, landing a big wet kiss on her mouth. Lucy felt his shaft poking her from underneath. She pulled away and hit his chest. "No! They are right there!" He grabbed her breasts and she smacked him in the face. He just laughed. "Alright the lady said get out. So get out." Natsu smirked down at his companions that were gapping at them.

Lucy screamed, "The show is over! Get the fuck out so I can fuck him again! You are not allowed to see it!" Their nakama all snorted while picking themselves up from the ground. Gray grabbed Juvia's hand. "I'm weirdly turned on. Wanna help me out with a little problem?" Juvia almost fainted in his arms as he carried her away. Levy simply gave Gajeel a seductive look as she turned away, and he followed without another word. Erza and Cana stared at each other. "Sorry Erza, but I don't roll that way. You'll have to find someone else to help with your urges." Cana squawked as she sauntered away, pulling a flask out of her purse. Erza flushed and followed her out, mumbling about how she didn't roll that way either.

Lucy had finally climbed down from Natsu and she slammed the door shot, locking it just in case. She whipped around. Natsu seemed a little sheepish now that he wasn't showing off anymore. She growled. "You are so going to get it right now jerk." She ran over and tackled him to the bed, somehow she had grabbed his scarf and tied him up again. She smirked down at him while he struggled against the new binding. "I'm going to repay you in full now, my little dragon." Lucy was in control the whole evening, wanting to punish him fully for embarrassing her.

Natsu and Lucy didn't show up to the guild for several more days, but now that all their nakama knew what was happening, they weren't worried. Gray, Juvia, Levy, and Gajeel seemed to be missing too. The guild mates laughed at the new sex addicts. Mira was whining at the bar, "Oh if only I could have left the bar to see such a sight! Oh I'm so jealous! Just think of the babies running around soon!" Cana had told the whole guild in descriptive detail everything that they had witnessed, much to Erza's dismay. The guild also had to give Cana lots of money- apparently they were betting on all the couples love lives. Cana was a master of cards, she loved to find future possibilities and gamble with them. She hardly ever lost a bet. Cana smirked at the barmaid, "Stop your whining and pay up matchmaker!"