Dang you making me cry! Beautifully written

This was really nice. It reminds me of some other SPN fics I've read. Makes you think: This is on the relatively "happy" scale for a SPN fic, whereas I just read a Harry Potter fic about this dark and the reviewers were breathing out imprecations against the author for writing such a depressing story.

... and now I'm crying. *sniff* This... it was amazing. Probably one of my top faves (not just a favorite to go on my list, but one of my favorite favorites). I just... it was brilliant. Everyone was characterized wonderfully, especially Sam, despite him being a restless spirit. It just figures that he'd stay behind for Dean rather than for himself. Excellent job!

Omg! I don't think I've wanted to cry while reading one of your stories before. But this one definitely got me there. xo

Wonderful. I can so see this happening. Lovely story.

oh i miss bobby even more now...sigh

This is absolutely beautiful. *sobs into fist full id tissues* absolutely beautiful.

The idea of same staying through "maybe just sheer perverse obstinacy" seems rather fitting dontcha think?

What a beautiful, touching story...It almost made me cry. Everybody is perfectly in character, especially Sam. It was beautifully heart-breaking.

Oh. Jeez. This was beautiful and heartbreaking and wonderful. I'm not much of a reviewer, but you had my tearing up. Bobby was so in character and and...my BOYS. SAMMY. Gah, this was brilliant.

Dean is the only one who could get through to a vengeful ghost Sam very sweet ending.

I'm just gonna just go right out and say it: you made me cry and I'm talking about the shameless "so fucking what if someone I know walks in and I'm floor rolling and gross sobbing" kinda crying.

It pains me to think that it would be sweet, innocent Sammy stuck behind caught up on grief while usually guilt-ridden Dean moved on. But it's also so like them for Dean to have to go first before Sam follows right on his big brother's heels. So basically is what I'm trying to say is hell of a job well done on such a hard concept to explore and be able to keep everyone in character while providing a literal emotional punch.

Aww! That was heartbreaking.

Damn - made me cry. This is heartbreaking. Well written.

You had me tearing up, poor Sam. Thanks for the read.

I can't think of any worse job for Bobby to have to take, short of his wife of course. This story was beautiful and heartbreaking. Great idea and great execution! Thank you.