It's been eight years, and counting; so far, this fanfiction has been one of my favorite and has claimed one of the top spots in the "reread" section of my note. Would probably like it even better if there were more chapters, though.

Please continue this story it is really good

This story is awesome.

I love it! Why is this not completed yet!

I've read many stories of Al dying but I have never cried while reading one till now. I want to shout at you but also praise your writing! It's just so sad and tragic but just amazing writing

I love this so much

Aaaaaaaaaaawesomeeeeeeeeeeeeeee!

I want Ed to punch Dumbledore.
It would be ever so satisfying, just like the time he clocked his dad in the face.
With either hand, metal or flesh.
...
Just my opinion.

Please update this! It's very interesting, and it's the only decent one that I've found that revolves around Hermione and Ed! It's a very interesting read, and I keep coming back to read the chapters over and over again. I would love a new one!

Why has this been abandoned!? It's amazing, please continue to write this story!

Please go back to writing this!

I am still Shipping Ed and Hermione

Update please

Awesome chapter!

Is this story on hiatus or up for adoption?