this is so beautiful and so fucking fantastic is it on ao3 please?

Okay so I don’t know if you still get emails from fanfic or if you’ve disappeared into the real world but I know that if someone wanted to rave to me about a ten year old fic I wrote I would want to read it which is why I’m still commenting.

I just reread PJO for the first time since about 2012 and, like any rational person, started reading fics after. And as I started reading fics I remembered this one. I vividly remember it from when it was first published. But apparently back in 2011 I didn’t favorite or follow this fic so it was lost to me. So, again like a rational person, I searched fanfic to find this story again. It took about three days of searching different phrases to find it (it took “Isle of the Blessed” and I’m truly shocked I hadn’t thought of searching that sooner).

Rereading this fic has been truly incredible and I’m not surprised at all I remember it so well. All three lifetimes are written so beautifully, how their relationship is similar yet different each time they meet. Thalia finding them in their third life and bringing them together (and being their friend!). The quest in their third life where they both decide to be themselves rather than someone else. It’s all so beautiful and incredibly written. This fic is one of my favorites - across all fandoms. Thank you for sharing it and bringing me joy 10 years since I first read it.

This has quickly become one of my favorite fanfics. Given that I’m writing this in 2020, you’ll probably never see this review. But I absolutely loved this.

Wow... this was... wow.

I read this about ten years ago. I remember absolutely adoring it, but I think I appreciate it more coming back as an adult to read it again. You have a wonderful writing style, and I enjoyed this so much.

What a wonderful story. Was truly an experience to read.

Best thing I ever read

This is an older story, and it’s 11:27pm, and I have read this story. I loved this, my favorite part was probably the ending, although I wish Annabeth and Percy could have met in the isle of the blest in the story, jt thats okay. I knkw you’ll never see this, but i just want to sau thank you for writing this.

Man. This was the most beautiful piece of fan fiction I think I’ve ever read. I cried. Thank you so much.

Pretty good.

Thank you for writing this.

Thanks for the chapter.

Thanks for the chapter.

Thanks for the chapter.

OH MY GODS! Your story is so beautiful!. I loved reading each and every word of it! I’m almost in tears right now. I feel something in me, almost like that feeling one gets before a roller coaster ride! Oh god. It’s just absolutely amazing. I’m in love with this story! I swear this is the most beautiful Percabeth fanfic I have ever read! Thank you for such an amazing work!