This story was so good! Thumbs up!

Love this storyline, great job

Great story, love it

Great story, love it. Nice writing

Great story

Have been adoring this so far. Your take on Freddie's teenaged mind is brilliant :)

This was an amazing story. I've been reading it over the past week, and you did a phenomenal job with it!

Great story

Love this story

The one thing that I love about this story is that it rings emotionally true. You really hit on the characters and their relationships between each other very well. I also really appreciated that you made Amelia a good GF for Freddie. Not many people do that. I was always the one who got dumped, so I really appreciated that you made her sympathetic so that I could empathise with her. Also, by closing out her story with her starting to move on was very touching and a much appreciated move.

What can I say, for all its faults, and in the past reviews I've more than laid them out, this story is one I keep coming back to. Yeah the fight scene was all wrong and I still think the kiss at the end wasn't enough of a payout, but what this story continues to have genuine emotion. Sadly, for iCarly in its 5th Season, Sam and Freddie might as well be cardboard cutouts compared to he depth of emotion that they should have grown into and especially compared to what you show here. This was an ambitious story when you first wrote it 3 years ago, and now I think that in its waning seasons, iCarly will probably never live up to this. Thanks again!

This was awesome. You're awesome.

I didn't necessarily like this *whole* story, but it did have a nice cascading bit of ups and downs. However, this chapter was just so perfect...the arguing, the back and forth is the same sort of stuff we've seen from season one on. And I hope, dear Lord do I hope, it continues on just like this. Keep up the great work!

this was so flipping amazing, words do not even begin to describe it. i read this whole damn amazing fic in a whole afternoon/evening, and a little in the morning BECAUSE I HAD TO FINISH THIS IT WAS SO ADDICTING. everything played out perfectly. that was just.. wow.

i had a longer review planned but i have to get ready for the day n stuff. HOWEVER i just wanted you to know that i love you and this fic forever and ever. amazing first person narrative (surprisingly it worked out, as there have been so many instances where it doesn't)- the writing style was purely amazing. the angst and the drama were all there.

i can't wait to see more of your writing. :) even if this was a super long time ago.

I reviewed this story about a year ago and commented on the rough ride you put our favorite duo through. Thought I'd give it another read to see if my perception had changed. I still love everything I'd mentioned in my last review. My comments on the fight scene still stand (even a year later that was a bitter pill to swallow) but over all, I still enjoyed this one. You manage to encapsulate the essence of a great Seddie story, at a time when the second season had only just begun. Congratulations on your foresight. My only new criticims would be with the Epilogue. Our reward at the end was a rather poiniant kiss. And yet I wanted more. These two have just gone through one heck of a roller coaster ride and it all comes to an end with a simple kiss. I'm not talking about a lemon here, but it just seemed like something with a bigger impact was needed. Oh well, one again, thanks for the story!