Snape and Albus are in character and the situation is believeable.
Nice job.

Poor Snape/Lily, doomed to failure by the Plot.

A great story. Very well written.

how come it's the more awesome fics, such as this one, which gte the least reviews?

This was beautiful. It was so poignant.

Two of my three fav characters in a oneshot mad of win.

(Although I still think Albus should have seen Gellert too in the morror, but that's just me)

So Dumbledore's obsession with socks has a reason!

Brilliant!

Very sad and well written. I wonder what Snape would have seen? Maybe Lily? It's refreshing to see attention given to some of the lesser known characters, and also nice to see Dumbledore so in-character. Two thumbs up.

Beautiful!

Thank you for this lovely story. I like the little details you added, like Snape scowling over the name "Fluffy." You really captured your character's personalities very well!

Really great, I love it! The parallel between Snape and Dumbledore is really cool.