Ah, love it!

You know what? I can totally imagine this happening to the brothers. I mean, Winchesters' luck right? This is a horrific incident but a good story. Cheers to you author!

This is the BEST hunt that went sideways. Although I have to say, I'm a cat person, so each and every mention of the furball had me laughing double. Poor fish. Interesting how calamity that follows the boys seems to escalate quite so fast, eh? But the way you write it, it's so laughable and fun. I love this! The banter, the hurt - getting themselves safe. Wonderful!

Fantastic premise! So very well written! You're AWESOME!

Even though the seriousness of this story, it's hilarious, I could really see Sam and Dean getting stuck in that situation.

But the poor cat was scared shitless

Wow, great story idea. You did a wonderful job telling it!

like your little disclaimer at the end ;)

Wow. What a premise. That was a great fic. I was wondering why there was no dead fish warning at the start but then that disclaimer at the end. xD

Awesome story liked it. It was incredible.

Great story it was unbelievable and I liked it.

what terrific story really liked it.

What a superb story.

Nice story! That was a cool idea and you nicely put it down into words! I liked the imagery of the house burning down because I could see it in my head! Loved the interactions as well! Good job :)

This was a outstanding story.