Sam and Dean might forgive John, but I never would.

The way John treated his children disgusts me. And I'm sick of this whole SPN series constantly trying to defend and justify John's actions after his death. Just because he sacrificed his life for Dean, it doesn't magically erase the horrible things he had done for past two decades.

I really, truly loved this...wish the show had done this...and just given us a few...even just a couple of episodes of the boys WITH their father before it yanked him away forever from their side. Given them some good memories to cling to, you know?

Ah, thank God for Bobby showing up to injecting some sanity into this mess...thank you...thank you...thank you!

It's awful, I know, but right here...at this point...John deserved that! And damn though, what it would have cost Dean to deliver that...it would really have devastated him.

Awww, it wasn't like it was bad enough what happened before and after all that you woke him to THAT nightmare...that's even meaner than Kripke was to him!

Oh, I don't like it, but not because of you...at the moment you are writing well within the parameters Kripke laid out for... vere left, vere right just don' t go straight his way, okay?

This was perfect. I didn't stop to review I was so engrossed. Sam and Dean...HELL YEAH KEEP ON GOING! Oh, my iPod played 'Fur Elise' and 'Time of Dying' at the worst times which made me laugh...in a bad way 'cause I sobbed hysterically afterwards. But stil awesome job!

I feel like a horrible person right now, but I can't stop laughing. It was what Dean said, " We kill out of love." It's just so... Sappy. I'm so sorry, this is a really good story. Just that part is.. Yeah.

I loved, loved loved this ending! So they said all the things that they never got to say on the show and Dean actually had a go at his father instead of following orders all the time and there is a happy ending. Great story I enjoyed reading it!

well I thought this chapter was really good and I love it when people bring Bobby nto their stories! Looking forward to reading the next and last chapter

thats an interesting twist to the begining of season 2! Just found this story the other day...onto the next chapter

This is amazing! I kind of love this story, it made me almost cry and my the end I was grinning like an idiot. I loved the ending and this was overall a fantastic extraordinary story. I'mma go add it to my favorites. :)

*~Anastasiavampirepixie~*

can't imagine dean saying that to john. hell, sam's done a lot worse and dean would never give him such an ultimatum.

Wow, awesome story!

OGM! That was a fantastic fic, i loved reading it. Keep writing fics please. salt n burn, hon. Jaz