I love this story. I really love Boromir, and I think you've captured him and shaped his character really well here. I love his friendship with Nineth. And the mentor/father-son relationship he has with Hallas. Really great job with this story, I really enjoyed it. :)

This is interesting. It's always interesting to me to read about the other perspectives of orcs, and the questions they arise.

A truly beautiful and wonderful story that was a joy to read.

A very good read.
A small aftertaste of the "unfinished" about it, but a great tale nonetheless.
The readers can continue the fable in their heads :)
Borys

This was a great idea!

That's a good story you wrote there...

Hi,

I love stories, where Boromir gets to live. And I really enjoyed yours! I read the whole thing without stopping...

I think it was very believable. I can just see the character of Boromir as so proud and stubborn, that he wouldn't be able to deal with his "Failure" in any other way... In fact, all your characters were very well written. Those we already know from canon were recognizable. And your original characters sounded like real people to me.
Your whole story made me feel, like it could have really happened in Middle Earth...

Thank you very much for sharing this story with us! I will certainly read it again!

I've read Faramir fics, and a heck of a lot of elf and hobbit fics, but never one about Boromir. This is quite satisfying :) I love it to bits and I hope I can read more soon

Never thought I'd read a fanfic about Boromir. I usually stick to Elvish Hurt/Comfort Romance Adventure, etc. But then again, here we are. Excellent job– I like how Boromir struggles with himself about going home, and I especially like how they all go to Gondor again together. I like to imagine how Frodo would react to seeing Boromir again...

Thanks so much! It was so enjoyable to read this!

This was a wonderful piece and I thank you for having written it.

I could imagine the anguish Boromir experienced and I really enjoyed reading this (all in one night!). Thanks again.

A very nice story... love it!

Can't believe I have only just found this fic! It's definitely going onto my favourites! :)

Fantastic story. You write really well, and I'm glad that Boromir is finally home with his family.

Beautiful story. You've created some great original characters. I'd really love to see Nineth's reaction was to finding out that Erandir was Boromir, of all people... Ah, well, I'll just have to be disappointed in that aspect. I'm glad you showed us that she is doing very well for herself! (Actually, the entire day when he gets back would be fun to see...)

You made me cry when Hiril died. Loved that dog...

I can so easily see and understand Boromir's feelings and fears during the reunion. I loved seeing them all get together again! I had to laugh about the idea of them all meeting up fighting Uruk-hai-great idea-and then, of course, you had to make me panic by making this so similar to the scene where he fell in the first place!

Well written. Great read.

Ah...I knew it would be a depressing end for them :(