| Reviews for Elanor's Revenge |
|---|
   Kindle-the-Stars chapter 37 . 6/18 I absolutely love this story - I remember reading it years ago, and came back to it now during coronavirus lockdown. It is beautifully written, with great pacing and characterisations. Very well done indeed and thank you for writing such a lovely story! |
| Guest chapter 6 . 1/25 You write well and I really wanted to like it but, on the basis that this is a romance and presumably she's going to fall in love with him, I'm finding the dynamic with Haldir too misogynistic and uncomfortable - he sexually assaults her and everyone seems okay with that? I think you need to rewrite this slightly and either tone his behaviour down or make her better at standing up for her rights and putting him in his place and showing him how awful his behaviour is. |
| Guest chapter 37 . 1/18 Aww are you going to write Lana s story? Such a great read |
| barbara chapter 6 . 12/4/2019 Haldir is creepy and awful. Everything from being abusive to molesting her naked after sending her to sleep with a spell. Wow. |
| Dee chapter 1 . 9/6/2019 In Unfinished Tales the name Nerwen is the name Galadriel's mother gave her when she was born. I believe it means "man maiden." |
| LadyConfidential chapter 37 . 8/24/2019 Wow! What an epic! It has taken me about a week to read this lovely story, however I am so glad that I did. Both your writing (which was enjoyable throughout) and your characters developed as the story progressed, and it was heartening to see happiness and redemption all around. At times, right at the beginning, Haldir was so patriarchal it was infuriating (poor Elanor!) but I loved your portrayal of him as a multifaceted character. I'm not sure if either of you are writing these days, but if you are, I would love to read more of your work. Well done :) xx LC |
| KathrannofQuade chapter 28 . 8/23/2019 Hahaha! I just have to comment half-way through this chapter...I freakin' LOVE the plant-talk. I laughed out loud when Haldir told Rumil the plants would complain to Elanor if he gave them the broth...This story is SO GOOD. I'll be sad when it ends... |
| leward1992 chapter 37 . 3/14/2019 Wonderful story. Thank you for writing this. |
| FangirlBookworm21 chapter 37 . 2/20/2019 Spectacular |
| Lisamalvina chapter 37 . 1/2/2019 Aaaaaaw! That was so sweet and incredibly cute. I loved reading this and I want to thank you for writing this! THANKYOUTHANKYOUTHANKYOU! |
| BeulahMae chapter 37 . 12/30/2018 I think this is the third time I have read this story, and it continues to be one of my absolute favorites! You are extremely gifted! |
| mystarlight chapter 24 . 12/26/2018 Breathtaking battle scenes! |
| mystarlight chapter 18 . 12/26/2018 Haldir on the archery field is awesome. |
| mystarlight chapter 17 . 12/26/2018 The scene with Rumil is hilarious. Poor Rumil! |
| mystarlight chapter 16 . 12/26/2018 What an ending! Love your story! |
