Reviews for The Sorcerer's Apprentice |
---|
Bagge chapter 4 . 6/28/2006 Ah, so that was what was going on. Nice end to a nice story. I enjoyed all paralells to Riddle's diary (a student died; muggle paperback book; a tall, dark-haired boy... you had me speculating for a moment). I must say that Clovis was a young man of high moral standing. Just imagine all the abuse he could have done with the book, but chose not to. And Ron will always be Ron. |
Bagge chapter 3 . 6/28/2006 A vile object indeed; and of course, another muggle notebook comes to mind. A very Dumbledorian aproach to the problem. Highly intruiging story. |
Bagge chapter 2 . 6/28/2006 Highly enjoyable to see how the students spent their time waiting for Harry to wake up. Very much Fred and George style firework. Oh! I think I start to realize what you are getting at. Well, Harry shouldn't be surprised. All good stories change when they are retold. But I must say that this is far more than a making fun of differences in movies and book. This is a good story in it's own right. Let's se how it will change, once retold. |
Bagge chapter 1 . 6/28/2006 Dudley is being his normal, charming bully self, and Harry his normal, miserable, sarcastic orphan self; but something is very wrong with the background scenery. I and Harry will have to find out together. |
Possum132 chapter 4 . 3/13/2006 This is such a clever little essay! Very enjoyable! |
Brooke Monroe chapter 1 . 12/4/2004 i don't get it. sorry. |
MrBen chapter 4 . 9/16/2004 The story was good up until the resolution of the mystery. It was too clean and kinda lacked any drama, which was a little disappointing as it was an excellent premise. |
Samhain13 chapter 4 . 3/6/2004 Ah, what can I say? Excellent. Do you strictly consign all your work to the Net, or do you have work in print as well? |
bleeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee chapter 4 . 9/28/2003 Hehe. I like the way you put the movie events in. Great fun to read. Well written as well. Thanks for a read. |