Interesting, very interesting! Maybe the Battle of Hogwarts would have gone differently had this really happened, who knows, but I love the idea. Sirius was always my favourite character and its comforting to think he could have returned in this manner.

I remember reading this from around 2003 or 2004. It's still one of the best Harry Potter stories ever written because of the imaginative plot and spot on characterizations. It's forever my head canon for what happened to Sirius, Remus and Harry. I hope you have a sequel to this. Going to check.

good story

Wow... Okay im 100% sure i like this way more than jkr's last two books... You are freaking awesome... Soo good... Thank you

This was just do unique! I have never read a story like this before. Loved it.

This story is so good! You have a way with words that I admire greatly.

oof I wasn't even alive on the 23rd of January, 2004

Wow, this was great! I loved that Sirius came back, and you write the ship so well.

Hey, so, I dunno if you're still on this sight, but I just wanted to review. First of all, I LOVED THIS THING. I was never such a big Sirius-comes-back-from-the-dead kind of person, just because I feel like dead is dead and that's it, but you make it so believable and your plot is great and your writing style as well, and I feel as though you didn't just keep it as a "he's a ghost" instead delving into Oneiromancy and the whole mirror thing and…that's a run-on sentence so I'm going to start a new one. :) Anyway, I've always been interested by dreams, and I did a project on them at school, so I was so excited to discover this adaptation of our Oneiromancy to the story. Also, just to let you know, I fell in love with Wolfstar (RLSB) for like the 1,000th time. Adore that pairing, so cute! Thanks so much for writing this, I really loved everyone and everything about it!

Hey, so, I dunno if you're still on this sight, but I just wanted to review. First of all, I LOVED THIS THING. I was never such a big Sirius-comes-back-from-the-dead kind of person, just because I feel like dead is dead and that's it, but you make it so believable and your plot is great and your writing style as well, and I feel as though you didn't just keep it as a "he's a ghost" instead delving into Oneiromancy and the whole mirror thing and…that's a run-on sentence so I'm going to start a new one. :) Anyway, I've always been interested by dreams, and I did a project on them at school, so I was so excited to discover this adaptation of our Oneiromancy to the story. Also, just to let you know, I fell in love with Wolfstar (RLSB) for like the 1,000th time. Thanks so much for writing this, I really loved everyone and everything about it!

I love Remus and Sirius so much and I'm so invested.

Oh my goodness how is this so good! Usually when people invent new branches of magic for fanfiction it's sounds like bullshitomancy but I really bought your entire premise! Very neat story, I can't believe it's been almost 14 years since you finished this (and I am very glad you finished it!)

I love this so much

This chapter has had the same effect as a bar of chocolate to me today

If Snape saves Sirius will I hate him less? It helps that you said it was AU and that it was before the later books were published