This is the CUTEST story! I loved it so much.

God I love this story! Is there any chance of a follow up chapter? I love the characters as you’ve wrote them here, especially Donna. Would a continuation

This is wonderful. It was so real. Loved it!

This was an absolute joy to read! It sounds so real and believable and above all so true to the characters, especially Josh's habitual tunnel vision and total focus to the exclusion of all else. I love it so much that it's Donna who asks for a date - actually I love all of it. Please give us more from that wonderful notebook. I for one want to read everything from it!

OMG. I love this! You don't need to be insecure about this fic, I really enjoyed it, and would love for you to continue it. P.S.: If you decide to continue, please keep it PG :)

I love this! The corndog line made me laugh- like, actually, genuinely brought a smile to my face. I love this take on things, and you always write them so well. You've definitely found the voice!

Nice story! It is fun to read other ways Josh & Donna could have met. You captured their essence in a believable scenario.

Great story. Perfect.

THIS IS NOT GARBAGE! Seriously, don't be so hard on yourself. Everything of yours that I've read has been absolutely lovely and a joy to read, and this is no different. Guard that notebook with your life. There's obviously some great stuff in there. I'm sure I'm not the only one who would like to read it. As always, thanks for writing and sharing.

Oh, and a big YES to the holiday fic!

This was very sweet. Don't sell yourself short!