Reviews for A Clash of Kings: Knees Falling |
---|
RWIW chapter 6 . 9/9/2019 Seriously consider a professional career. Without having read ACOK, I can’t tell what’s your writing and what’s Martin’s. Scream Against The Storm is even better, and it wouldn’t be amiss to post it here... but anyway, this is amazing stuff. I read your ‘Woman of His Dreams’ story as well and liked it. You’re an impressive author. |
ZenJack chapter 11 . 9/4/2019 Shits for Davos. |
Herraidous chapter 11 . 7/28/2019 Hi! This is a great story; I've finished all of it so far, but I thought I'd leave a review here. Have you ever read Ben Kane, Steven Erikson, Simon Scarrow? You write like a fully fledged author; your realistic and unflinching ability to kill off characters and write tragic, desperate, blood and shit bespattered battle scenes is what sets this story apart. Great job, when I look for ASOIF this is what I'm looking for. I noticed you haven't updated A Storm Of Swords, are you planning to continue with that? I hope you do, this is fantastic! |
MegaMindAuthor chapter 1 . 7/12/2019 Beautiful! The writing is just but a notch closer to Martin's. The description, explanation and thoughts of characters are layered like ink on parchment. They fit writing is smooth and elegant. The characterization is good but my lack of knowledge on Creesen is not that well so I cannot say. Very well done. |
thepkrmgc chapter 3 . 3/24/2019 I'm sure that renly will find a way to mess things up somehow... |
thepkrmgc chapter 1 . 3/24/2019 props to cressen for his backup plan, hopefully she wont find a way to heal it off |
Fils chapter 6 . 1/18/2019 Why would Catelyn think she would be able to do anything? This was just stupid of her. She just acknowledged that Renly would be willing to let House Stark and Lannister destroy each other if it meant he would be King, and everyone knows Stannis's character. Why would she believe that her testimony of supporting Stannis's claim that Cersi's children are not trueborne will do anything, especially since every "proof" that she has is speculation. I guess its just Cat being Cat then, instead of turning back to home she does something she's not suppose to do. Really loving this so far tho! |
Guest chapter 29 . 9/29/2018 This is an awesome story, one of the best I've read. I just have a minor quibble though. In the original, Renly's Rainbow Guard went by alliteration Robar the Red, Brienne the Blue, Guyard the Green, Parmen the Purple, and then he just stuck Bryce and Emmon with orange and yellow because he didn't have any friends with O and Y names. But here it seems you've stuck them randomly. Not that it even matters. But I thought it was cute and indicative of Renly's childish and playful personality. |
Guest chapter 16 . 8/22/2018 Is Loras dead? That would explain Renly's bitterness. Nice looking story - I like a 'King Renly' fic which doesn't whitewash him |
Sage of Wind Dragons chapter 28 . 5/13/2018 nice talks and arguments. Edmure gets so shafted by others its nice to see him as is right now. wonderfull stuff! |
Sage of Wind Dragons chapter 27 . 5/13/2018 nice change! hell even doing joffery some justice... nice work. |
Sage of Wind Dragons chapter 26 . 5/13/2018 wonderful work! and yeah they are cut form the same cloth. but hoyl HELL someone beat renly please. dam it I get this si n excersise in what would renlys survival do... but still. |
Sage of Wind Dragons chapter 23 . 5/13/2018 nice! now Tyrion, Joffery, and SHireen ahs to paly out Stannis quest of being the ship lead armies. and hell so many other places ready to raise the crowns ont he other kdis... and armies to match them! like Rob CAN and wills till bleed renly as much... and Renly losing his shine and splendor... alognw ith his gayness and not having children... hes been wasting men like water I wonder when the hemorging is going to hit on him? oh i cant WAIT for all the fun!. |
Sage of Wind Dragons chapter 22 . 5/13/2018 yeah a thing that was sqrewy to me is how few mentioned battles are all of the war which can be... set pices and all? but well. doom. but yes loras is dead! |
Sage of Wind Dragons chapter 21 . 5/13/2018 YES thank you and yeah. Edmure always gets shafted by EVERYONE. but it is nice. her over confidence a sa woman who DOESNT knwo war is odd... but hey. thigns going. but good remined by author of thigns that can be lsot track of as now. but yeah disaster and everyone going SIDEWAYS. sheeesh. |