When I clicked on this story, I didn’t realize that I had already read it a year ago, but when I remembered I decided to go ahead and read it again, anyway. And I’m so glad I did! Because I read it as a guest and couldn’t save it and now I can! Yay! So I got to this chapter (and again, I’ve read this story before) and was SUPER excited to see the Relient K song as a header. Well, I went through the comments and found that I commented about loving them already. XD All that to say, I love this band, and I’m glad I was able to find this story again because it’s so good and fluffy and sweet. Thanks for sharing it with us!

Not where I thought it might go, but I adored the very-un-creepy, winking Santa chapter

Ohhhh a creepy winking Santa! Love this already

Can I please Thank you a billion times for not wrapping a feverish Sam with all of the blankets Dean can find? It really takes away from the flow of the story when an author does that, when you know it's the opposite of how to treat a high fever. Very refreshing. Thank you (x 1 billion).

I felt bad for Brianna knowing what was going on but not being able to get people to believe in her. I loved that she went up to Sam and that Sam and Dean were able to help out Brianna. And I loved that Jessica is the one who helped the girl get to Sam and Dean for help. This was really good and I really loved this.

I was not expecting Sam to loose his leg...that was not cool. I did like how you focused though on Sam wanting a normal life which is very much Sam right then.

This is interesting and heartbreaking for what Sam is going through. I love that Mary got back and immediately could tell something was wrong. I loved that she stepped in and helped so much with both Sam and Dean.

I loved that you did a Sam and Castiel friendship one. I do love how their friendship grew. It was horrible for Sam being in this situation and I love that Castiel found him and was able to get him to the hospital to get taken care of. I love that Dean was there but I'm glad it focused on Sam and Castiel's conversation at the end with Dean still by Sam's bedside.

I love seeing these moments. I like how both Jess and Dean are in this one, though obviously not at the same time. I love that it shows just how important they both are to Sam.

I really liked it. It was interesting how things ended up going with them. I loved how Sam and Bobby were able to have that conversation and he helped Sam get out of there. I really loved this one and I love Dean and Sam's conversation at the end.

I liked how Mary came to for Christmas with Sam and Dean. I do like how you write her because it's so much of her portrayal in the show. You capture it quite well. I loved how she talked to both Sam and Dean. It was nice having Mary there to take care of Sam but I loved how Dean was there a step ahead and she of course realizes why.

I really loved reading all these parts throughout Sam's life of the different Christmas experiences he had and his thoughts on it. I loved how it built up and the end part between Sam and Dean is really great.

I love having Sam have a conversation with Santa. I liked how the conversation went and how things were explained. I think you're right and it's a good time for Sam to have that conversation. I liked how it ended though.

I loved the whole aspect with Jack Frost. I liked that it wasn't him and that it was actually something else. I didn't blame him for getting upset, not that I wanted Sam to be frozen, but you know. I am glad that he did go back to Dean and they were able to stop her. I also liked how you had Dean's thoughts very much keep going back to the idea of him having to kill Sam and that at the end he's going to bury it and just keep Sam safe.

Poor Sam hurt and seeing Lucifer. I did like how Sam was trying to ignore him even though he was persistent. I felt so horrible for both Sam and Dean-Sam was hurt in more than just one way and Dean for worrying about losing Sam for good. I wasn't sure how they were going to make it out of there and I loved that Bobby was able to get them saved. I do like the conversation between Bobby and Dean and I loved the end scene.