Reviews for All Relevant Evidence
Black Tulip chapter 71 . 8/27
I have no idea if I ever reviewed this story, though I've read it several times over the years (seriously, 5 or 6 times since 2016). I just wanna say it's WONDERFUL. I usually stay away from original characters in fanfics, but Regan's pretty compelling. Plus I love how you manage to weave the different stories together. Not a big fan of Neil Gorton either, he comes off as sleazy as hell in the show so it's not too much of a stretch he'd pull of something like this. But it makes sense the only thing he'd really care about is his daughter. The only thing I object to is Abbie having jumped into bed with Jack. I wish they'd just been friends. Sexless friends. But that's just me. Everything else is perfect.
mccoylover chapter 71 . 12/24/2016
Always so many subtle references to canon that I am afraid I will forget to praise them all! The reference to Hawthorne was believable and would definitely have gone through Jack's mind in a conversation like the one you wrote.

His secret relief at not being asked to leave his life in NYC to follow Regan on her trips is reasonable and speaks of Jack's age, as well as the passion in is life that will always take the fore front, personal relationships will not change that.

Huge deal for Jack to clearly tell her not to go...too bad it isn't going to be enough.

Really wanted to see these two have a happily ever after, but that would have been contrary to the characters ...well characterizations :)

All I can hope for now is a sequel (which, since I was so late reviewing, I already know is in the works). Really outstanding story. I, like several others would've LOVED to see this series acted out on either the big or small screen...even an audio book would have been FUN!

Damn you Dick Wolf for 1. letting LandO end and 2. for not taking advantage of ths truly remarkable FF writers talent!
mccoylover chapter 70 . 12/24/2016
Really sweet piece that convincingly conveys the awkwardness of starting a live in relationship... btw,I am with Regan on the whites/colors separation rationale.

Just painful to see Regan still hesitating to completely trust her heart, even though she has a numerous supply of good reasons not to.
mccoylover chapter 69 . 12/24/2016
You, Mistress off McCoy Writing, are a big tease...but in a good way. Nice way to bring Tom "back to life", so to speak.

I also liked Jack's parenting tips :)
Guest chapter 71 . 12/12/2016
Oh no, is it over already?
Great story anyway.
I really hope you'll write the sequel!
dersty chapter 71 . 12/11/2016
What a great story. Like I said before, I love all of your Jack McCoy stories. I hope there will be more of him soon.
katiejeanrose chapter 71 . 12/11/2016
is this the end?! :'(
nooooo
Guest chapter 70 . 12/11/2016
Really hot
Carol chapter 70 . 12/10/2016
Hot.
Carol chapter 69 . 12/10/2016
Wow. I remember back in one of your early stories a throw-away line about Regan having been pregnant.
Carol chapter 68 . 12/10/2016
Oh no!
dersty chapter 69 . 12/9/2016
Glad Tom was okay.

It would be cool to see a series on Jack, Regan, Abbie, and Tom with the new baby. Just a thought.
dersty chapter 68 . 12/8/2016
No :( Poor Abbie.
vandevere chapter 68 . 12/8/2016
Poor Abbie...

Losing Tom just before the baby's birth. Thank God for Regan and Jack.
mccoylover chapter 68 . 12/8/2016
Very nicely done. Good of you to save something so bittersweet, yet in the end hopeful and Gorton's disillusioning actions. You did take me by surprise with Tom. Wow. Very real situation done very realistic emotions for a woman like Abbie.
177 | Page 1 2 3 4 11 .. Last Next »