A/N: I had so many plans to update this after different story lines, but I never got around to it.

This chapter doesn't take place during a super specific time, just some time after Seth joined The Authority.

I was inspired by the beautiful song "Wanted" by Hunter Hayes for this chapter.

I added Roman to this chapter and it was interesting because I normally only write Roman and Seth as a couple, so it was a challenge to keep them as just friends.

Be sure to check the author's note at the bottom!

Here's the summary for this chapter: Sometimes Seth feels like the odd man out in his relationship. John and Randy have to make him feel wanted.

Disclaimer: I don't own any of the wrestlers, they all belong to WWE. If I owned John, Randy, or Seth, I'd never leave my apartment.

Wanted

"Keep it down. I don't want you to wake Seth," John whispers into Randy's ear.

Seth is sleeping peacefully on the other side of John's California King Bed. Randy is pinned underneath John and John is slowly thrusting into him. Randy woke up restless and horny, so John decided to help him out. They've been fucking for a little more than twenty five minutes and Randy is ready to cum.

John has to place his hand over Randy's mouth so that his moans don't disturb Seth. Randy orgasms and John follows right behind him. When John rolls over to Randy's left side, he finds a pair of beautiful brown eyes staring up at him.

"Why didn't you wake me up?" Seth asks in a groggy tone.

"Because you always look so peaceful when you sleep. I didn't want to bother you," John explains.

"You can always wake me up for sex," Seth lets him know.

"I'll remember that next time," Randy replies.

"Randy and I are starving and we want to get some breakfast. Are you hungry?" John questions.

"Not yet. You two go eat. I actually want to go see Roman today," Seth answers.

John kisses Seth on the forehead. "Have fun. Tell him that I said hi."

"You seem down," Roman notices.

"I just have a lot on my mind," Seth says.

"Tell me what's going on," Roman encourages.

Seth sighs. "It's my relationship. Everything started out great. They both accepted me with open arms. And I'm growing closer to Randy now that we're working together a lot. But lately, I really feel like the odd man out when all three of us are together. Like I'm practically the third wheel. John has this connection with Randy and I'm not sure if he'll ever have that same one with me. They were having sex this morning and I almost felt like I was intruding on a private moment as I watched. I just sometimes feel a little neglected by John."

"John and Randy have been together for six years now. They've known each other for even longer. John is just more familiar with Randy. Yeah, they have a strong connection. They can probably read each other's minds at this point. But don't confuse their familiarity with John not loving you. I've witnessed firsthand how much he loves and cares for you, Seth," Roman tells him.

"I don't expect him to love me as much as he loves Randy because they have been together longer, but sometimes I just honestly feel left out. I know it probably sounds stupid," Seth responds.

"It doesn't sound stupid, but you shouldn't feel like that. John decided to tell everyone about your relationship to protect you," Roman reveals.

"What? How would you know that?" Seth wonders.

"Because I overheard a conversation between him and Randy. Brock was being a dick and saying some inappropriate shit about you. John told Randy that the only way that the guys would leave you alone is if they knew that you belonged to them. So, he and Randy decided to tell everyone about your relationship," Roman informs him.

"John never told me that specifically. He just said that he thought it would be better if everyone knew," Seth replies.

"You can be a little . . . dramatic sometimes. I'm sure John didn't want to risk upsetting you," Roman states.

"I do sometimes bitch about John and Randy babying me. But the truth is that I love that they care so much," Seth admits.

"Have you tried talking to John about how you feel?" Roman asks.

"No. I think that it would be awkward to tell him about my insecurities," Seth says.

"But if John doesn't know that there's a problem, then it won't get fixed," Roman states.

"That's true," Seth agrees.

"And you never know, John might have insecurities too. He might be struggling with the fact that you and Randy are growing closer," Roman points out.

"I kinda hate that you are so wise sometimes," Seth playfully tells Roman.

"It's one of my many charms," Roman responds.

"Thanks for the advice. I really needed it," Seth expresses his gratitude.

"No problem," Roman says.

Seth is surprised to find John's house empty when he gets back. He checks his phone and he sees that he has an unread text from John that was sent an hour ago. Seth opens the message and he frowns when he reads it.

John: Taking Randy to the airport. He has to go home. Don't worry. Love you.

Seth is typing back a reply when he hears the front door open. He knows by the sound of the heavy footsteps coming up the stairs that it's John. Seth puts his phone down and sits up in bed when John comes into the room.

"My alerts weren't on, so I didn't read your text until a few minutes ago. What's going on with Randy?" Seth wants to know.

"Family drama. He didn't really go into detail, but he said that it's nothing major. I can read Randy like a book, so I believe him," John informs him.

"I trust your judgment," Seth says.

"The silver lining of the situation is that we get to spend more one on one time together," John mentions.

"I like the sound of that," Seth comments.

John and Seth have just finished eating an expensive Italian dinner. John has one more surprise up his sleeve. He slips a blindfold over Seth's eyes before they drive away from the restaurant. Seth keeps trying to guess where John is taking him and John just laughs at his impatience.

"We're almost there. You're going to love it," John promises.

Seth gets excited when he feels the car stop. He's desperate to know where John has taken them. He reaches over to take Seth's blindfold off. Seth's eyes immediately observe his surroundings. They're sitting in an empty parking lot and there's a big screen several feet in front of them.

"We're at a drive-in movie theater! I've always wanted to go to one," Seth explains.

"I remember you telling me that on our third date," John recalls.

Seth's eyes grow wide. "Wow. I can't believe that you remembered that."

"I remember things that are important to me," John replies.

Seth smiles brightly at John's sweet words. John explains that the movie they're going to see is some old horror movie that he's never heard of. Seth really doesn't care what they watch just as long as they watch it together. They lean their seats back and get comfortable.

Seth loves that they're all alone. The warm summer breeze gently blows Seth's long hair. The moonlight illuminates John's deep blue eyes and Seth just admires how beautiful that John looks. Seth reaches over and he slowly runs his fingers over John's cheek and along his strong jaw. It has felt like a lifetime since Seth has touched John intimately.

"I'm really glad that we did this," Seth says.

"Me too," John agrees.

"I was starting to get paranoid," Seth tells him.

"Paranoid about what?" John wants to know.

Seth nervously bites his lip. "Your feelings for me. I feel like we were close when we first got together. And then I don't really know what happened to us. It's like we drifted apart. I've been growing closer to Randy lately and it's really great. But when all three of us are together, I feel left out. And it's been a while since it's been just the two of us. We don't connect like we used to."

"Randy felt the same way at the beginning," John admits.

"Really?" Seth asks.

"Yeah. I had to explain to him that I needed to make you feel welcome and comfortable. I had to spend more time with you so that we could bond and truly fall in love with each other. I knew that it was going to take Randy a longer time to connect with you, so I wanted to bond with you first. Randy really doesn't like many people, so I wanted him to really get to know you. You're so lovable, so I figured it wouldn't take a long time for Randy to realize that. I've distanced myself a little bit to make sure that you and Randy love each other as much as I love both of you. That's the only way that all three of us can be happy," John explains.

Seth nods in understanding. "That makes sense. I was just confused because we were spending so much time together and then we weren't. I was thinking that I did something to make you not want me anymore."

"Seth, I love you so much. I can't imagine not wanting you. I hate that I made you feel unwanted," John whispers.

"I'm ok now that I understand what's been going on. You were leaving space for me and Randy to grow. Now we're all on the same page," Seth concludes.

One Week Later

Seth wakes up to John sucking his cock and Randy's mouth on his neck. He moans at the unexpected pleasure. John runs the flat of his tongue along Seth's shaft and Randy sucks on the tender skin just below Seth's ear.

"Good morning," Randy whispers.

"Good doesn't even cover it," Seth manages to get out between groans.

John chuckles at Seth's response and the vibrations from his laugh make Seth mumble incoherently. Randy knows that Seth is going to cum soon because he can feel Seth's body tensing underneath him.

Randy nibbles on Seth's earlobe at the same time that John gently scrapes his teeth across the very sensitive underside of Seth's dick. The pleasure that Seth is receiving from both of his lovers is driving him crazy.

"Feels so good. Both of you. Fuck!" Seth exclaims.

Randy licks the outside of Seth's ear and then he surprises him by dipping his tongue inside. Seth squirms at the unfamiliar sensation. John relaxes his jaw and he swallows Seth's cock until he feels it poking the back of his throat. Seth is always amazed by John's lack of a gag reflex.

"I think John gets more pleasure out of sucking you off than you do," Randy softly tells Seth.

Seth wants to verbally agree with Randy, but he's incapable of proper speech. John is looking up at Seth with half-lidded eyes and that's almost enough to trigger Seth's orgasm.

Randy turns Seth's face toward him and he brings their lips together almost violently. Their teeth clash together before Randy's tongue makes it into Seth's mouth. Randy's rough treatment of Seth is always a perfect complement to John's gentler nature. Randy grabs a handful of Seth's hair and softly tugs on it. Seth's moan is muffled, but John and Randy still hear it.

Seth is so into kissing Randy that he doesn't immediately notice John's slick finger at his entrance. He pushes his thick finger in just beyond the knuckle and he feels for Seth's prostate. John knows when he strokes it because Seth's eyes roll into the back of his head and his toes curl. Randy releases Seth's mouth just in time for him to let out a loud cry of pleasure.

"Shit, Johnny! Keep going! I'm so fucking close!" Seth shouts.

Randy pinches Seth's nipples while John continues deep throating Seth while fingering his special spot. Seth is sweating profusely and there's a blush covering his entire body. Seth is enjoying the tag team stimulation from his boyfriends.

"I'm cumming!" Seth yells.

John removes Seth's dick from his mouth just in time for the first shot to cover his lips. Seth shakes uncontrollably and the rest of his cum splatters John's chin. Randy crawls toward John and he licks every drop from John's face, savoring the flavor of Seth's release.

Seth kisses Randy and he ends up getting a little bit of his own cum on his tongue. He turns toward John and brings him close for a passionate kiss. John swallows the last trace of Seth's cum and he groans at the taste of Randy that's mixed in. There's nothing sweeter to John than the taste of his two lovers.

"That was one hell of a wake up call," Seth remarks.

"We just wanted to remind you how much we love, need, and want you. You're everything to us, Seth. We're not three separate parts anymore. We belong as one," John replies.

Randy rolls his eyes at John's sentimental words, but he doesn't say anything to contradict them. John and Randy's relationship was great before Seth. But there was always a sense of something missing that they could never quite figure out. They now have their missing part. Now that they have found each other, all three men finally feel whole.

A/N: I've had a lot of fun writing the 3 of them together, I really have.

This is the final chapter of this fic (Sad face).

But I am going to write more John/Randy/Seth fics in the future!

My other John/Randy/Seth ideas don't fit within this fic, so that's why I decided to end this here and now.

I look forward to hearing all of your thoughts as always!