Author's Note

Hi everyone! Welcome to my second fanfiction, Caught. This is sweet, not smut, so if I leave you wanting more, I apologize! Thank you to Ficklepucker for the inspiration for Kurt/Burt/Blaine. It was going to be a one-shot, but I'm pretty satisfied with the first half and not the last half, so thought I'd separate it while I kept working.

If you have not read Hold On, please do so. It is my love letter to Klaine, my Blaine backstory, and the one story that I have always wanted to tell. Caught takes place prior to Hold On, after "Prom" and during "Funeral." You could read it before or after, but please, if you haven't ready Hold On, please do!

Kurt and Blaine sat in the dark movie theater, staring at the screen, quietly holding hands beneath the seats. Next to them Finn and Quinn made out shamelessly, as did most of Kurt's McKinley High classmates surrounding them. Kurt was both repulsed by and jealous of the affections on public display here. Occasionally, Kurt and Blaine made eyes at each other, but they both knew it could go no further than that. Despite the support they received at Prom, outside of school events they were still cautious. They were surrounded by letterman jackets from both the football and hockey teams, and even with Finn there to back them up, they weren't interested in ruining the evening with a fight.

Kurt wasn't sure why he agreed to this double date. He and his boyfriend typically tried to stay closer to Westerville than Lima, where it was a bit safer for the two of them to be together. However, Finn wanted so much to go out with them; it was hard for Kurt to say no. And he knew that Blaine was trying to foster a relationship with his boyfriend's stepbrother. Truth was, the conversation over dinner went very well. Quinn was on her best behavior and chatted with Kurt about Nationals and Coach Sylvester's worsening attitude, while Finn and Blaine went on about sports. Every once in a while, Blaine would look over to Kurt with a huge grin on his face, and Kurt could almost see the "thumbs up" in his eyes. Kurt blushed, thinking about how important it was to him that Blaine and Finn got along.

The movie ended and Blaine and Kurt headed to the bathrooms, leaving Finn and Quinn outside. The boys had shared a giant diet coke, while the other couple had been too occupied to bother with the snacks they had bought. When they came back out to the lobby, they could not see the other two. Blaine leaned against the wall casually to wait in case they came back. Kurt stood in front of him, restlessly scanning the crowd. Blaine soaked in the perfection before him. Kurt Hummel stood in black skin tight jeans that made Blaine's heart race and his mouth turned into a smile. Teenage Dream indeed, he thought!

"We need to find them so I can get home. You should go, you need to get back to Dalton," Kurt said, darting his eyes into the crowd, trying to find his brother.

"I don't want to let you go yet," Blaine said, with a hunger in his eyes.

Kurt turned to look at his boyfriend, with a smirk. "Blaine Warbler, are you trying to seduce me?" Kurt teased as quietly as possible.

"Let's not go home yet Kurt." Blaine's eyes glistened. "I want to hold you, and kiss you, and run my fingers down your chest to your…"

"Blaine!" Kurt hissed, looking around to see if anyone is listening.

"Come on baby, let's go somewhere," Blaine pleaded, taking his hand.

Kurt pulled his hand away, even though he wanted to just melt into Blaine. "I'll miss curfew. You'll miss curfew. Come back to my house. Dad will let you stay for a few minutes before you have to go back."

"We can't be alone at your place," Blaine whined, hands rubbing his neck in an attempt to keep them off of his absolutely gorgeous boyfriend, "I want to be alone with you."

Kurt smiled a giddy grin. Blaine wanted to be alone with him! He almost jumped for joy at what Blaine was saying. How could he possibly think of saying no? "Where would we go?" Kurt asked breathlessly.

Blaine thought for a minute. He couldn't think of a better choice. "Come back to Dalton with me," he said.

Kurt stared at him. "Blaine, by the time we get there, it will be after curfew. If we get caught…"

"We won't get caught," Blaine said with surety. "I know a place. Please Kurt," he said with such need in his eyes that it made Kurt's heart leap. "Watching everyone else…I just want to hold you so badly right now."

Kurt stared at his boyfriend in his tight blue jeans and close fitting black crew neck. He knew he should say no, but he had lost all power to resist the beautiful man in front of him. "Fine," Kurt said quickly, "I just have to let Finn know." But at that moment he heard Finn and Quinn in the crowd, fighting over something. Something ridiculous, no doubt, thought Kurt. Something I don't want to get in the middle of.

His brain told him not to, but he didn't listen. "Fine, let's go," he said, and he and Blaine rushed out of the movie theater to Blaine's car.

Blaine grabbed Kurt's hand and led him to a quiet and secluded spot on the beautiful and sprawling campus of Dalton Academy. They arrived only minutes after curfew, so the dorms and buildings were locked. Unable to wait any longer, Blaine pulled Kurt down into the grass and pushed him onto his back. Blaine slowly leaned over his boyfriend, and kissed him longingly. They had not been alone since Kurt transferred back to McKinley. Their relationship had grown since then, especially after prom night. But they had rarely had the chance for romance. Kurt was always so careful, so watchful of everyone around him. And Burt never left them alone in the house. Tonight, Blaine thought, is a luxury and I want to take advantage of every moment.

Kurt's heart swelled, as Blaine kissed him. He was nervous, but he was also excited to finally be alone with his boyfriend. When Blaine carefully touched his tongue to Kurt's lips, he hesitated only slightly to allow Blaine entrance. He felt Blaine's skin heat with passion, and Kurt leaned into him, moaning slightly at the deliciousness of Blaine's lips and tongue. He grabbed Blaine's hair, and worked his fingers through to release the curls from their gelled prison. He twirled a curl around his finger and pulled slightly. He could feel his own pulse race when Blaine's hand worked its way down Kurt's chest, over to his hips and down to his thigh. Kurt held his breath as Blaine massaged his more tender spots that had yet gone unexplored. He felt Blaine hesitate only a moment before starting to make his way toward his inner thigh. Was he going to…? Kurt flinched instinctively.

Blaine wanted to explore every inch of his boyfriend's body, but he felt Kurt tense up as he moved his hand slowly lower. Blaine understood that Kurt needed to take things slowly, although he ached for more. He returned his hand to Kurt's chest, and caressed him while he tenderly kissed Kurt in reassurance. Kurt relaxed beneath him and leaned in hungrily for Blaine's lips, instantly forgetting Blaine's wandering hands. When Kurt pulled away for a moment for air, Blaine whispered to him, "Did you go through those pamphlets your Dad gave you?" Blaine had been amazed when Kurt told him what his father did. While it was his idea for Burt to have "the talk" with Kurt, Blaine found himself jealous of how supportive Burt was.

Kurt was shocked and embarrassed at the question. He found it hard to answer, so he only nodded. Even in the dark, Blaine could see Kurt blush and his forehead furrow. He cursed himself for asking such a forward question at a time like this. Blaine traced Kurt's blush with his finger tips, stroking his thumb gently on Kurt's cheeks, kissing each dimple. He then brought his hand up to Kurt's eyes. Blaine brushed his fingers over Kurt's eyebrows, and Kurt closed his eyes, allowing Blaine to place one gentle kiss on each gossamer eyelid. He brought his kisses to Kurt's forehead, erasing the worry lines from his perfect complexion. He moved his lips to Kurt's neck and suckled for a minute before nibbling on a silky soft earlobe.

"I'm scared too, you know," Blaine whispered in Kurt's ear soothingly.

Kurt's eyes shot open and he looked deeply into those compassionate hazel eyes. "Really?" he asked with uncertainty. Blaine had seemed so confident that day when he offered to tell Kurt what he knew about sex. He remembered the kind of excited look Blaine had at the time, eyes gazing up at him. Then and now, he didn't see fear in Blaine's eyes, he saw longing. It was that longing that scared Kurt the most. What if Blaine found out Kurt wasn't really the boy he wanted?

Blaine saw Kurt's trepidation and wanted more than anything to soothe him. "I think everyone must be their first time. Kurt, I'm not saying I'm ready tonight. But I know that when I am ready, when we are ready, there is no one else I would rather share my fear with than you. The only person I want to share myself with is you," Blaine said with surety.

"How are you so sure?" Kurt asked breathlessly. He watched as Blaine's hazel eyes bore into his own, darting back and forth considering…something. For a moment, Blaine had a faraway look in his eye, but before Kurt could question it, it turned into a fierceness as Blaine leaned into Kurt and kissed him as if his life depended on it. When they both needed to take a breath, Blaine pulled away slightly meeting Kurt's eyes. Kurt saw pain in them.

"Because you are my light in dark places, when all other lights go out," Blaine said.

Kurt's eyes watered, and he blinked away tears. "What dark places?" Kurt asked, worry in his voice, reaching his hand out to cradle Blaine's cheek.

Blaine hesitated to answer, when both boys heard a noise behind them and a flashlight shine in their eyes. "Ahem…" They quickly sat up to see one of the Dalton teachers, Mr. Remy, standing over them. "Headmaster's office," he glared at the boys. "Now."

I hope you enjoyed Part 1. This is a short story, and the other parts are written but in the middle of revisions, so updates shouldn't take too long. Please let me know what you think so far, I'm a little unsure of the whole thing. The more reviews I get, the quicker the rest will be posted. It's magic how that works!