A sequel to Waffles...

From Pie to Tots

Chapter 1

French Silk Pie

Finn devoured his third piece of pie, savoring the creamy taste and rich flavor. He heard a small cough and looked across the table. Kurt was smiling at him from the other side next to a nervous looking Dave. Finn smiled, it had been nice for Dave to bring over pie... all six of them. Finn wondered the coincidence that it was his favorite pie.

"His mouths full," said Kurt.

"Not yet... wait until he's full.. that way... I can run if I have too," said Dave in a whisper.

"Mmm.. my god, this is delicious," said Finn taking another bite.

"David made it from scratch," smiled Kurt, Dave gave a nervous smile.

"Yeah... do you like french silk," asked Dave, playing innocent.

"I love pie... oh this.. is.." Finn took another bite and dropped his fork, "So good.."

"So.. full?" asked Kurt, glancing at Dave, Finn murmured a yes, "David?"

"Oh dude... were these pies for something?" asked Finn quickly, misreading their looks.

"Oh no... I uh... just had something to tell you," said Dave, giving a nervous smile.

"What? You made cookies?" beamed Finn, he was joking... but maybe... just maybe.

"I'm gay," said Dave biting his lip, Finn blinked.

"Seriously?" asked Finn, licking his teeth and raising his brow, wondering if maybe more pie... wait no.. focus.

"Yes," said Dave, Finn smirked and nodded.

"Puck owes me forty bucks, score," chuckled Finn.

"What?" asked Dave and Kurt both looking shocked.

"I totally called it Freshman year... I mean it was a joke... but I'm totally banking on it... is that why I got pie?" asked Finn, looking around the table, hoping maybe some more of his friends had secrets that resulted in food treats.

"Were dating," said Kurt, Dave looked at him quickly and stood as Finn glared, "Finn..."

"... pie," said Finn, pointing at the pie, they slid the pie over to him, he nodded and it was silent.

"So..." said Kurt, Dave shrugged as Finn ate.

"You do realize that I will maim you if it ends badly right," said Finn, his mouth full of pie.

"Yup..." said Dave, glad how this had gone down.

"So that makes Puck and Finn," said Kurt proudly, a plate was slammed down both looked at Finn.

"You.. he.. Puck knew...before me?" asked Finn, his brows narrowed, Kurt's eyes went wide and Dave darted to the other side of the room, "He knew before me? Are you serious!"

"We didn't exactly tell him," said Kurt quickly.

"He kind of came in on us after..." Dave trailed off.

"Your having sex!" yelled Finn, "AND PUCK KNEW BEFORE ME!"

"Finn, calm down..." said Kurt, as Finn advanced towards Dave, who was trying to maintain a calm stance.

"... french silk pie for life," said Dave quickly, holding his hands up, Finn froze and blinked.

"... for life..." said Finn, Kurt was signaling something behind him but he couldn't see.

"Yes..." said Dave, Finn's glare faded and he smiled happily.

"Welcome to the family," said Finn, pulling Dave into a hug, Dave looked at Kurt in confusion who was glaring.

"What... it worked," said Dave proudly.

"Yeah but unlike Puck... Finn will track you down for the rest of your life... imagine being seventy years old and Finn just... shows up for pie," said Kurt eyes wide, Dave snickered.

"Its kind of funny," said Dave.

"Yeah well a panda bear is cute till it kills you," said Kurt, eyes wide, he sighed and smiled, "But that's one more person who knows now."

"This is actually kind of interesting... who's next?" asked Dave, resting his forehead against Kurt's.

"... my parents..." said Kurt with a small shrug, Dave paled, Kurt kissed his nose and headed into the living room.

"..." Dave sat down in a stooper, horrible outcomes playing in his head after what Burt might do after he found out.

"Man... that sucks..." said Finn, Dave got up quietly, "I mean Burt's gonna flip over the dating... imagine if he finds out you two are... is that ice cream..."

"Yes..." said Dave holding out the container, Finn blinked at it, then snatched it, "Also... if I die... no pie..."

"... I will make it my personal mission to protect you two and stand by all your decisions," said Finn with a stern nod, "You can count on me."

"Glad to hear... because I may possibly shit myself."

TBC