A/N: I know I said this wouldn't be posted until I felt seven by seven, but I'll be leaving on Friday for a couple of weeks and I'm not sure how my internet service is going to be.
Rachel quickly saved her relationship status and logged off the computer. Finally, after two months of uncertainty and bouncing back and forth, her boys finally figured out the best thing for her. Sam and Noah had approached her the week prior and told her their idea: Date both of them, at the same time. They wanted her and she wanted them, so what was to stop her? Her fellow gleeks made things difficult with their constant questioning; now they had their answer.
Grabbing her phone off her desk, she put it on silent and turned to where Noah and Sam lay on her bed, both of them grinning at their phones and snickering.
"Babe, you started a storm," Noah said, looking up at her.
Rachel shrugged and looked at them through half-lidded eyes. "I'm done with Facebook for now," she murmured pointedly. Being the smart guys that they were, they put their phones on her bedside table. Rachel crawled between them on the bed, allowing them to kiss her cheeks before she cuddled against them, Noah on her left and Sam on her right.
They lay there, the guys arms wrapped around the petite brunette. "You okay?" Sam asked, breaking the silence.
"Hmm? Oh, yeah, I'm fine." Rachel smiled up at him before pressing a kiss to his lips. She started to pull away but his fingers tangled in her hair, holding her securely in place as he explored her mouth. Her moan grew louder as Noah ground his hips against her arse and peppered her shoulders with kisses before his mouth found that spot on her neck. She gasped into Sam's mouth, whimpering as the blond dipped his hand below her skirt, drawing odd patterns on her knickers over the wet spot they had created.
Noah's hand trailed up and down her side before snaking under her shirt, his long fingers dancing along her abdomen. She sucked in, clutching Sam's shoulders as Noah cupped her breast and Sam's deft fingers slid beneath her knickers. Rachel wrenched away, gasping, as Puck unlatched her bra.
"Oh! No, we ca-" Noah silenced her with a hard kiss. Sam began working her knickers down with one hand while the other began unbuttoning her shirt, his large mouth kissing the newly exposed skin.
"It's okay, Rach, we promise." He nuzzled her neck. "Just let us take care of you, love." Not giving her a chance to refuse, Noah dipped back down, capturing her lips once more and forcing her to lie on her back as Sam pulled her knickers off her ankles. The blond geek grabbed one of her pillows and settled it under her hips, lifting her up and exposing her pussy to him. Sam noticed how tense her thighs were and began kissing her ankle, rubbing her foot gently. Puck shot him a look and Sam nodded. The darker boy trailed kisses down her slender neck, stopping at the more sensitive places to bite down, then soothing with his tongue.
Rachel whimpered as Noah latched onto her nipple while Sam kissed her inner thigh, blowing cool air on her aching centre. Sam finally (finally!) thrust his tongue inside her and one of her tiny hands speared through his mop of hair while the other carded through Noah's Mohawk as they continued their simultaneous assault.
Noah tweaked the nipple he doesn't have in his mouth as Sam pushed a finger into her, sucking on her clit.
"Noah… Sam… Please," Rachel gasped, her hands pushing their heads closer to her body as that delicious feeling began building in the pit of her stomach.
"Tell us what you need," Sam hissed against her before continuing his ministrations.
"I-I-I-"
"Say it," Noah whispered, biting her nipple before switching sides.
"I-I need… Ohgodohfuckrightthere!" Her hands clenched spasmodically, her nails digging into their scalps as she tumbled over that wonderful edge. Sam kept working his finger in her, helping her ride out her orgasm. Puck left a trail of hot, wet kisses up her chest to her neck before placing a chaste kiss on her lips and tugging Sam up to join them. The blond tilted her head up, kissing her slowly and sweetly before releasing her.
Rachel sighed, snuggling between them. "I'm glad we did this," she murmured, her eyes already drooping closed.
"Me too," both boys said, kissing her forehead and wrapping their arms around her tiny body. Within moments, her breathing evened.
"Her dad's will be home in a couple of hours," Sam whispered.
"Yeah, but we can let her sleep for a bit," Puck whispered back.
They interlaced their fingers together over her hip and lay back, intent on resting a bit before her dads interrupted their personal time with their girl.
Knock knock knock!
Sam jolted awake, blinking stupidly before realized that someone (probably one of her dads) is knocking on her door. He shook Rachel and Puck awake as whoever was on the other side called out, "Rachel?"
"Yes, Daddy?" Rachel called back.
"Dinner will be ready in twenty minutes. Are your boyfriends going to stay to eat?"
Rachel blushed, thinking about their activities earlier, and Sam winked at her, stretching to work out the kinks. Her eyes lingered for a moment on the expanse of skin where his shirt rode up.
"Yes, they'll stay for dinner," she finally replied.
Rachel's fathers had been unexpectedly cool about their precious daughter having two boyfriends, especially since they knew about each other and it was their idea in the first place. Rachel assured them that they were going to be using protection 'should they engage in intercourse,' which made her fathers feel better, surprisingly.
They heard him walk away and Rachel crawled off the end of the bed and turned to stare at the two impossibly hot guys stretched over her bed.
"Where is my underwear?"
A/N: I know it's not much, but here it is, the sequel to Facebook Shuffle. I may or may not continue this, going into what the school thinks of this newest Gleek scandal… And more sexy times… If not, I have another idea, which I will write, regardless if this particular story goes on.
But it will only continue IF YOU ASK FOR IT! Normally I don't ask for reviews, but this time, I really need to know if you want this to continue, so please drop me a little message :)