Disclaimer: I do not own any of the characters or the show.

I wasn't thinking about Channy when I wrote this so it might not mach exactly. I know it has lots of rough spots and I would love constructive criticism. I know it totally sucks though so you don't need to say it. If it will help me with my writing then go ahead but otherwise opinions to yourself please.

Katherine out =D

Normally when people cry during chick flicks, it's because they feel for the characters. I cry because that Noah guy is the luckiest bastard I have ever seen. The girl he loves has a horrible boyfriend and she's better off leaving him for Noah. But what if the girl you loved had a boyfriend who loved her?

What if he didn't cheat?

What if he didn't lie?

What if he treated her like a queen?

What if he makes her happy?

He's no better than me. I would do all those things too, if I ever got the chance. I love her just as much as him. I'm just as good looking (if not better looking).

The only difference is he has her.

But What if I didn't cheat?

What if I didn't lie?

What if I treated her like a queen?

What if I made her happy?

I would love to hate him, I would love to be angry, and I would love to be right. But how can I hate someone who didn't do anything. How can I hate someone who made her happy?

What if it was me?

Would he hate me?

I know this sucks and its really short. Just an idea I had.