The Challenge!

Background: Ai and Mai are twin sisters who moved to Ouran Academy from an all girl Boarding school in Tokyo. They are two gorgeous red heads who have all the guys drooling over them, but they have never found one boy worthy of dating them. In order to date them you must be able to tell them apart and handle their lesbian tendencies. They've yet to find someone who can, but some group of girls told the about Hikaru and Kaoru in the host club. They are on their way to find out if they can tell the two apart. They want someone to be able to tell them apart more than anything.

Girls POV

We walked into the music room and saw a tall man with glasses. We were so excited to meet the twins.

"Um, excuse us." We said in unison, "How do we go about getting a host?"

"Ah, welcome ladies," Replied the man in the glasses, "Are you new here?"

"Yes," We answered blushing. It was a little embarrassing being new.

"Well how can I help you?" He asked.

"We're looking for Hikaru and Kaoru." Ai said.

"We wanted them as our host today." Mai finished.

"Well it just so happens you're in luck. They have nobody else today so you will have them to yourselves," He smiled putting away his book, "so right this way."

The tall man in glasses took us across the room to where the twins were sitting. When we saw them all we could do was look at each other and smile.

Boys POV

"Hello," Hikaru said, "How are you,"

"Beautiful ladies today?" finished Kaoru.

They started blushing and giggling as they introduced themselves. We could tell that the two of them are really close, maybe even as close as the two of us. They look cute enough; maybe we'll have some fun with them.

"You're new here, correct?" Hikaru asked.

"Yes, we came from an all girl school in Tokyo." One of them said, "Oh we should introduce ourselves, I'm Ai."

"And I am Mai" finished the other one.

"Yes, we see," said Kaoru, "Ladies will you excuse us for a second?"

"We'll be right back." Hikaru smiled.

We got up and walked to where we were out of their earshot.

"Did you know twins were coming to this school?" Kaoru asked.

"No, I had no idea. They look exactly the same." Hikaru, "We could have some fun with them though."

"We could," Kaoru agreed with a mischievous grin, "Let's play the 'Who's Hikaru' game."'

"This should be good." Hikaru said as we made our way back to where we had left our clients.

Girls POV

The brothers came back and sat down.

"Well girls we have a game to play." Kaoru said.

"If you're OK with it," Hikaru added.

""Sure." Ai agreed.

"We love games" Finished Mai.

"Alright, the name of the game is which one's Hikaru." They said in unison again. They then got up and put on hats, "Can you guess who's who?"

"Well, the one on the left is Kaoru." Ai said in a matter of fact tone.

"And the one on the right is Hikaru." Mai finished.

"Sorry ladies, but you're incorrect." They smiled.

"Oh, but we're not. We were right." We said looking at them. It wasn't hard for us to tell them apart because we ourselves were twins and played this game, "It isn't hard for us to tell twins apart."

They looked at each other for a long time then decided to respond. "How could you tell us apart?"

"Well we too play this game quit often. Telling us apart is the only way we agree to go on a date with someone." Mai said.

"Yes and that means we've yet to have a date, but maybe… you could tell us apart. Would you like to try?" Ai asked, her eyes filling with joy.

"Well, we… " Said Kaoru.

"Of course we would," Answered Hikaru.

We got up and went behind the column and when we came out our hair was tied back in ponytails so it wouldn't cover our eyes.

"Who's"

"Who?"

"Well, the one on the left is …" Kaoru hesitated.

"Ai!" Hikaru proclaimed confidently.

"Yeah, and the one on the left is Mai." Kaoru said backing up his brother.

We sunk back into the couch. "We really wanted to date you." We pouted.

The brother just sat there with their mouths open.

Boys POV

"You have to be kidding us." Kaoru whined, "We lost at our own game?"

"Well, they do look exactly the same." Hikaru replied.

"So do we, but they could tell the difference between us." Kaoru continued to complain.

"Oh, don't be such a baby." Ai said.

"Yeah that really is a turn off," Agreed Mai.

"Well what's the secret to telling you two apart?" Hikaru asked.

"Well that's simple" Mai laughed,

"All you have to do is look at our eyes. My eyes are slightly darker than Mai's" Ai explained.

"That's it? That's the only difference?" We asked puzzled.

"Yep, that's all we know of, but your only difference is the part of your hair and we still got it." Ai said.

"Don't rub it in." Kaoru crossed his arms over his chest.

"Well, there has to be a way to be able to get a date with the two of you lovely ladies." Hikaru pleaded.

"You could try again." We said looking sad.

Just then Haruhi walked by while looking at Tamaki and she crashed into the couch the twin sisters were sitting on.

Girls POV

"Oh here, let us help you." We said knelling down to pick up the shattered tea set.

"Oh, that's not necessary." The girly man responded.

"It's no problem we do this all the time because were such …. Owww." Mai said holding up her finger. She had cut it and was bleeding.

"Here," Ai said taking the finger with her hand, "Let me see it."

Ai took the finger and wrapped a napkin around it, and then when it stopped bleeding she took it into her mouth and sucked it for a few seconds. She took it out from her mouth and kissed it.

"Does that feel better?" Ai whispered smiling naughtily.

"A little bit."Mai looked down while blushing a bit. We get up and realize all the guys in the room are staring at us in shock, and all the girls are staring at us with jealousy.

"Don't be embarrassed. The girls just don't understand our bond." Ai said pulling Mai's face closer to hers, stopping just a few centimeters away.

"We understand." The brothers said quickly, "It's a special bond that only twins share."

"Yes, they understand us." Mai said, her face lighting up.

"They may understand us, but they can't tell us apart." Ai said pouting.

"Well how about when you visit tomorrow we guess again." Kaoru suggested.

"Yes, and we'll make one guess a day until we get it right." Hikaru agreed.

"That sounds fair enough." Ai said.

"It's a deal." Mai finished. "I didn't know you'd be so interested in dating us."

"Were not, we just don't like being beaten at our own game." Kaoru said a bit too quickly.

"And the fact that we've never dated twins before." Hikaru admitted.

"Well you have a month. At the end of the month if you have not guessed correctly we must stick to our rules and never date you." Ai said.

And there it was. The brothers had just been given a challenge that they were determined to complete.